The present invention relates to a method for separating a saturated
fatty acid and an unsaturated fatty acid from a mixture of fatty acids by a dry
fractionation process with a superior efficiency, and use of the separated unsaturated
fatty acids.
Background of the Invention
Fatty acids are widely utilized as an intermediate raw material of
foods, such as a monoglyceride and a diglyceride, as well as an additive, and an
intermediate raw material for other sorts of industrial products. These fatty acids
are generally produced by hydrolyzing a vegetable oil such as a rapeseed oil, a
soybean oil, or an animal oil such as beef tallow, using a high pressure method,
or a decomposition method with an enzyme.
However, fatty acids produced simply by hydrolyzing an animal oil
or a vegetable oil as described above, which have natural fatty acid compositions,
are not necessarily suitable as a basic raw material for industrial use. In other
wards, it is necessary to fractionate unsaturated fatty acids and saturated fatty
acids depending on the utilization purpose.
Therefore, it becomes necessary to modify a melting point to obtain
a desired mixture of fatty acids. Generally in a fractionation process of fatty
acids, a fractionation process using a solvent and a fractionation process using
a wetting agent are employed. Although these processes show high efficiencies (e.g.
yields) of separation, they pose problems such as an initial cost for facility investment
as well as a high running cost for recovery of the solvent or the aqueous solution
of the wetting agent and the like. In contrast, a dry fractionation process without
using any solvent (e.g. a no solvent process) is an inexpensive fractionation process,
and an attempt to solve such problem as low filtration rate, has been made by employing
an emulsifier such as a polyglycerol ester of a fatty acid (JP-A-11-106782).
However, even with the dry fractionation process using a polyglycerol
ester of a fatty acid, it has become apparent that sufficiently large crystals are
not formed under some conditions of cooling rate, retention time or the like, resulting
in a low efficiency of filtration.
Disclosure of the Invention
The present invention provides a method for producing a saturated
fatty acid and an unsaturated fatty acid by fractionating the saturated fatty acid
and the unsaturated fatty acid by adding and mixing a polyglycerol ester of a fatty
acid to a raw fatty acids mixture and cooling them to deposit crystals, wherein
a cooling procedure is performed at a cooling rate of 4°C/h or less when an supersaturation
ratio is 60 % or more, and said cooling rate is varied during the cooling.
In addition, the present invention provides a method for producing
a glycerides mixture from the unsaturated fatty acids fractionated by the above
method, in which at least 90 % by mass of the fatty acid components are unsaturated
fatty acids.
Detailed Description of the Invention
An object of the present invention is to provide a dry fractionation
process for fatty acids using a polyglycerol ester of a fatty acid, enabling to
shorten a cycle time and provide an improved efficiency of filtration, quality,
and yield by controlling cooling conditions.
Therefore, the present inventor has extensively studied the cooling
conditions after adding and dissolving a polyglycerol ester of a fatty acid, and
found that when a cooling rate is a specified rate and is varied during the cooling,
saturated fatty acids and unsaturated fatty acids can be efficiently fractionated,
since a crystal size of saturated fatty acids in a raw fatty acids mixture becomes
large and a formation of fine crystals is restrained, resulting in a remarkable
improvement in an efficiency of filtration.
Furthermore, the present inventor has found that the method is particularly
useful for producing glycerides for foods, because the glycerides mixture produced
from the unsaturated fatty acids thus fractionated contains less trans-form of unsaturated
fatty acids and is liquid state free from deposit of crystals at an ordinary temperature,
and thus accomplished the above invention.
In the present invention, "a dry fractionation process" means a process
to perform solid - liquid separation by cooling a raw fatty acids mixture while
stirring if necessary, without using water in an amount such as to allow a phase
separation and without using any solvent, and separating a solid component deposited
thereby using a separation system such as filtration, centrifugation and sedimentation.
" A composition of fatty acids" means the composition of the total amount of fatty
acids derived from free fatty acids and the fatty acid residue in glyceride. A composition
of fatty acid can be measured by gas chromatography. "A ratio of saturated fatty
acids" means the ratio of saturated fatty acids (C12 to C22)
in such composition of fatty acids. "A clear melting point" means a value as measured
according to Standard Methods for the Analysis of Fats, Oils and Related Materials(Japan
Oil Chemists' Society) (2.2.4.1-1996).
In the present invention, a raw fatty acids mixture to be fractionated
to saturated fatty acids and unsaturated fatty acids is produced by hydrolyzing
a vegetable oil such as a rapeseed oil and a soybean oil, or an animal oil such
as beef tallow, by a steam decomposition method, by utilizing lipase as a catalyst
or the like. In this connection, fatty acids include a monoglyceride, a diglyceride
and a triglyceride in addition to fatty acids. Further, unsaturated fatty acids
include some amount of saturated fatty acids, and saturated fatty acids include
unsaturated fatty acids. Still further, glycerides include some amount of fatty
acids in addition to the above monoglyceride, diglyceride and triglyceride. The
method according to the present invention is effective when an amount of fatty acids
in a raw fatty acids mixture is preferably at least 50 % by mass, particularly at
least 85 % by mass, and the above glycerides may be present therein. Furthermore,
as a raw fatty acids mixture, those having a ratio of saturated fatty acids (C12
to C22) such as palmitic acid and stearic acid in the fatty acid components
in an amount of 5 to 60 % by mass, particularly 8 to 50 % by mass, are preferred.
For instance, fatty acids originated from a vegetable oil such as a soybean oil
and a sunflower oil can be employed.
Origin of a polyglycerol ester of a fatty acid to be used in the present
invention is not limited. The ester may be any of those obtained by esterification
of fatty acids and a polyglycerol of natural origin, and those obtained by esterification
of fatty acids and a synthetic polyglycerol produced by polymerization of glycidol,
epichlorohydrine or the like. An average degree of polymerization of the polyglycerol
in the polyglycerol ester of fatty acids is preferably at least 3, particularly
at least 4, from the viewpoint of obtaining a crystal state easy for filtration.
Further, the fatty acids to be reacted with a polyglycerol are preferably composed
of saturated or unsaturated fatty acids having carbon atoms of 10 to 22, particularly
12 to 18, from the viewpoint of obtaining a crystal state easy for filtration. Said
fatty acids may be composed of a single fatty acid, but are preferably composed
of a mixture of fatty acids from the viewpoint to obtain a crystal state easy for
filtration. An esterification reaction between the polyglycerol and the fatty acids
may be performed by any of methods such as a method in which a mixture of these
substances is added with an alkaline catalyst such as sodium hydroxide, then directly
esterified in an inert gas stream such as nitrogen at 200 to 260°C, and a method
in which an enzyme is used.
The above-described polyglycerol ester of a fatty acid may be used
in combination of two or more kinds, and an amount thereof to be added is preferably
around 0.001 to 5 % by mass, more preferably around 0.05 to 1 % by mass, based on
the raw fatty acids mixture.
According to the present invention, as described above, saturated
fatty acids and unsaturated fatty acids are efficiently produced, by adding and
mixing a polyglycerol ester of a fatty acid as an additive to a raw fatty acids
mixture, cooling them to deposit crystals, and fractionating to a liquid portion
and a crystal portion. In this connection, the liquid portion is unsaturated fatty
acids and the crystal portion is saturated fatty acids. Said polyglycerol ester
of a fatty acid is preferably mixed with the raw fatty acids mixture and dissolved
therein at a temperature higher than the clear melting point thereof so as to be
completely dissolved in the raw fatty acids mixture.
It is necessary that a cooling procedure is performed at a cooling
rate of 4°C/h or less when a supersaturation ratio is 60 % or more and the cooling
rate is varied during the cooling. The supersaturation ratio is a value as calculated
using the formula (1), and represents a concentration (abbreviated to C) at a certain
temperature (abbreviated to t) so as to range from 0 to 100 % within a metastable
zone.
Supersaturation ratio = C(t) - Cs(t) / (Cu(t)
- Cs(t)) × 100 (%)
Definitions of solubility (abbreviated to Cs), supersolubility (abbreviated
to Cu) and metastable zone are described in page 434 of "Kagakukougaku Binran, 5th
revised edition" (published by MARUZEN CO., LTD). In the present invention, in formula
(1), "concentration" means a ratio of saturated fatty acids (C12 to C22)
in the liquid portion. A supersaturation ratio becomes 100 % when a concentration
(abbreviated to C) is equal to a supersolubility (abbreviated to Cu) at a certain
temperature (abbreviated to t), and the supersaturation ratio becomes 0 % when a
concentration is equal to a solubility (abbreviated to Cs).
Here, when a solution and a free solute coexist in an equilibrium,
the solution is called as a saturated solution and a concentration of the solute
in the solution is called as a solubility. A curve showing a relation between solubility
and temperature is called as a solubility curve.
In addition, the supersolubility is explained as follows. When a solution
in an unsaturated zone is slowly cooled, crystals do not deposit at a temperature
at which a concentration equal to a solubility, but deposit when the cooling is
further continued to some extent. Temperatures at which crystals starts to deposit
are measured for various solutions having different concentrations. A relation between
the temperatures and the concentrations is called as a supersolubility. A curve
showing the relation between temperature and concentration is called as a supersolubility
curve.
A metastable zone means a zone enclosed by the supersolubility curve
and the solubility curve.
Crystallization can be proceeded in a short time by cooling rapidly
and set a supersaturation ratio so as to become 100 %, but too rapid cooling tends
to lower an efficiency of filtration because crystals become fine due to an insufficient
crystal growth. Contrary, when a supersaturation ratio is 0 %, crystals do not deposit.
In the cooling procedure of the present invention, it is necessary to control a
cooling rate at 4°C/h or less when a supersaturation ratio is 60 % or more, from
the viewpoints of forming large crystals providing a high efficiency of filtration,
restraining formation of fine crystals, and obtaining an improved quality and yield.
Furthermore, by varying a cooling rate during the cooling, cycle time can be shortened
and crystals with better filterability can grow efficiently by restraining formation
of fine crystals, compared with a cooling at a constant rate. An average particle
diameter of crystals is preferably at least 100 µm, more preferably at least 200
µm.
Cooling rate is preferably varied at least once, more preferably 2
to 4 times. The cooling rate is preferably high at the initial stage of cooling,
reduced when a supersaturation ratio becomes 60 % or more, then raised again when
the supersaturation ratio becomes below 60 %. More preferably, the cooling rate
is 5 to 20°C at the initial stage of cooling, reduced to 4°C/h or less when a supersaturation
ratio becomes 60 % or more (more preferably 70 to 95 %), then set to 1 to 10°C/h
if necessary when a supersaturation ratio becomes below 60 % (more preferably 30
to 55 %). The cooling rate may be adjusted so as to vary smoothly immediately before
and after the change of cooling rate.
The final temperature of cooling depends on a kind of a raw fatty
acids mixture and a required quality of the product. For instance, when a soybean
fatty acids mixture is used as a raw material, the final temperature is preferably
-5 to 0°C. Further, a solution is preferably agitated during the cooling in order
to form large crystals with a high efficiency of filtration and restrain formation
of fine crystals. More preferably, a solution is agitated at an agitation speed
of 10 to 200 rpm.
As a separation method for the crystals formed, any system such as
filtration, centrifugation and sedimentation can be applied, and any of a batch
process and a continuous process may also be employed.
By using the solid - liquid separation according to the present invention,
saturated fatty acids can be separated as a solid portion more efficiently and an
effective components such as vitamin E present in a raw oil can be localized in
a liquid portion.
A liquid portion obtained by the solid - liquid separation is unsaturated
fatty acids. Therefore, a glycerides mixture which contains unsaturated fatty acids
in a ratio of at least 90 % by mass of the total fatty acid components can be obtained
efficiently by reacting unsaturated fatty acids thus obtained with a glycerol in
the presence of lipase.
Said reaction of unsaturated fatty acids mixture and a glycerol is
preferably performed using an immobilized lipase. Here, if a lipase with a high
regioselectivity is used, a glycerides mixture, which contains at least 50 % by
mass of diglyceride containing unsaturated fatty acids in a ratio of at least 90
% by mass of the total fatty acid components, can be obtained. Among such glycerides
containing a high ratio of diglyceride, those containing 50 to 100 % by mass of
diglyceride are preferable, and those containing 70 to 100 % by mass of diglyceride
are more preferable. On the other hand, if a lipase with a low regioselectivity
is used, a glycerides mixture, which contains a triglyceride as a main component
containing unsaturated fatty acids in a ratio of at least 90 % by mass of the total
fatty acid components, can be obtained.
Lipase may be used in a free state, but is preferably used in an immobilized
state on an ion exchange resin, particularly on an anion exchange resin. The above-described
reaction of unsaturated fatty acids mixture and glycerol is preferably performed
while removing water formed by the reaction from the system by means such as vacuum
dehydration, inert gas purging and use of a water absorbing agent in order to obtain
an improved yield of the esterification. Details of these reactions are described,
for instance, in JP-A-57-8787 and JP-A-1-71495.
Examples[Method for measuring supersaturation ratio]
First, a raw material to be fractionated was added with a polyglycerol
ester of a fatty acid and stirred at a certain constant temperature for at least
72 hours. The mixture was filtrated and a ratio of saturated fatty acids in a liquid
portion was measured. This procedure was repeated several times at various temperatures.
The ratio of saturated fatty acids thus obtained were plotted against the temperatures
to obtain a solubility curve [Cs(t)].
Next, each sample collected from each liquid portion described above
was cooled while stirring at a constant cooling rate (0.02°C/min) to determine a
temperature at which fine crystals started to deposit. This procedure was repeated
for the samples having different ratio of saturated fatty acids. The ratio of saturated
fatty acids were plotted against the temperatures at which fine crystals started
to deposit to obtain a supersolubility curve [Cu(t)].
Furthermore, a ratio of saturated fatty acids in the liquid portion
was determined at a certain temperature during cooling and designated as C(t).
A supersaturation ratio at a temperature t°C was calculated from these
results according to the formula (1).
Example 1[Preparation of a raw fatty acids mixture 1]
Soybean oil was hydrolyzed by a conventional method (a high pressure
decomposition method) to prepare a raw fatty acids mixture. A composition of fatty
acids, a ratio of saturated fatty acids and a concentration of fatty acids in the
fatty acids mixture used are shown in Table 1.
[Fractionation of fatty acids 1]
To 1,000g of the fatty acids mixture prepared above, a 2 g of a mixture
of polyglycerol esters of fatty acids (decaglycerol ester) shown in Table 2 was
added and homogeneously dissolved at 80°C. Then, the mixture was cooled under the
conditions shown in Table 3 while stirring at 50 rpm. A supersaturation ratio at
a temperature range from 20°C to 15°C during the cooling was 60 % or more. Subsequently,
using a filter cloth made of nylon, such as NY1260NLK (trade name, manufactured
by Mitsubishi Kakoki Kaisha, Ltd.) (filtration area: 39 cm2), the solution
was filtrated under a pressure of 0.03 MPa, and fractionated to a liquid portion
(unsaturated fatty acids) and a solid portion (a crystal portion ; saturated fatty
acids). A filtration time required to obtain 500 ml of filtrate, a melting point
of the liquid portion, a yield of the liquid portion, and a ratio of fatty acids
(C12 to C22) in each of the liquid portion and the solid portion
were measured. Results are shown in Table 4.
As apparent from Table 3 and Table 4, the following can be understood.
Namely, when cooling is performed under the conditions where an supersaturation
ratio is 60 % or more and a cooling rate is 4°C/h or less and varied during the
cooling, saturated fatty acids and unsaturated fatty acids can be efficiently separated
by a dry fractionation process, since large crystals of saturated fatty acids grow
in a short time restraining formation of fine crystals. In contrast, a cooling procedure
at a too high rate is not preferable due to a decreased efficiency of filtration,
and a cooling procedure at a too low rate is also not preferable due to an extended
cycle time resulting in a higher cost. Thus, it is preferable to set the conditions
so as to complete the cooling within 20 hours.
Next, results of production of a glycerides mixture using a fatty
acids mixture produced by the method of the present invention will be described
hereinbelow.
[Preparation of a raw fatty acids mixture 2 (enzyme method)]
A mixture of 5,000 g of a soybean oil, 3,000 g of distilled water
and 500 g of an immobilized enzyme obtained by immobilizing lipase AY (Amano Enzyme
Co., Ltd.) on an anion exchange resin (Duolite A-568 : ROHM & HASS Corp.) was
reacted at 40°C for 15 hours while stirring under a nitrogen atmosphere. The immobilized
enzyme was then removed by filtration and the sweet water was removed after leaving
for standing. Subsequently, 50 % by mass of distilled water heated to 70°C based
on the reacted oil was added to the oil and stirred well under a nitrogen atmosphere,
and then an aqueous phase was removed after leaving for standing. This procedure
was repeated twice followed by a vacuum dehydration at 70°C to prepare a raw fatty
acids mixture. A composition of the decomposed fatty acids is shown in Table 5.
[Fractionation of fatty acids 2]
A 3,000 g of the fatty acids thus obtained was heated to 80°C and
added with 6 g of the polyglycerol ester of fatty acids shown in Table 2 to obtain
a homogeneous solution by heating at 80°C for 15 minutes. The solution was then
cooled while stirring at 50 rpm, under the fractionation condition No. 2 shown in
Table 3. Subsequently, the solution was divided into three portions, each of which
was filtrated under a pressure of 0.03 MPa, using a filter cloth [made of nylon,
NY1260NLK (trade name, manufactured by Mitsubishi Kakoki Kaisha, Ltd.)] (filtration
area: 39 cm2 ). Results of analysis on a composition of fractionated
fatty acids are shown in Table 5.
Example 2[Production of diglycerides mixture 1]
A mixture of 868 g of a liquid portion of the fractionated fatty acids
obtained in the above [Fractionation of fatty acids 2], 132 g of glycerol and 50
g of an immobilized lipase (Lipozyme RM IM; Novozymes A/S) was reacted at 50°C for
2.5 hours under a reduced pressure. After the reaction, the immobilized lipase was
separated from the reaction liquid by filtration. The reacted oil thus obtained
was subjected to molecular distillation at 230°C and 0.05 mmHg to remove fatty acids
and monoglycerides. The distilled oil obtained was acid-treated by adding 2 % by
mass of a 10 % aqueous solution of citric acid and stirring at 70°C for 30 minutes
under a nitrogen atmosphere followed by vacuum dehydration at 70°C. The acid-treated
oil thus obtained was then washed by adding 50 % by mass of distilled water heated
to 70°C based on the acid-treated oil, and stirred well under a nitrogen atmosphere
followed by separating an aqueous phase after leaving for standing. This procedure
was repeated twice. The washed oil obtained was then subjected to steam deodorization
at 230°C for 60 minutes under a reduced pressure to obtain a diglycerides mixture
containing less saturated fatty acids and less trans-acids. Results of analysis
on a composition of fatty acids in the diglycerides mixture are shown in Table 5.
Example 3[Production of triglycerides mixture 1]
A mixture of 868 g of a liquid portion of the fractionated fatty acids
obtained in the above [Fractionation of fatty acids 2], 60 g of glycerol and 50
g of an immobilized lipase obtained by immobilizing lipase AY (Amano Enzyme Co.,
Ltd.) on an anion exchange resin (Duolite A-568 : ROHM & HASS Corp.) was reacted
at 40°C for 8 hours under a reduced pressure. After the reaction, the immobilized
lipase was separated from the reaction liquid by filtration. The reacted oil thus
obtained was subjected to molecular distillation at 230°C and 0.05 mmHg to remove
fatty acids and monoglycerides. The resultant distilled oil was then subjected to
steam deodorization at 230°C for 60 minutes under a reduced pressure to obtain a
triglycerides mixture containing less saturated fatty acids and less trans-acids.
Results of analysis on a composition of fatty acids in the triglycerides mixture
are shown in Table 5.
Comparative Example 1
Furthermore, results of production of a glycerides mixture produced
from fatty acids produced by a distillation method will be described.
[Fractionation of fatty acids 3 (distillation method)]
A 3,000 g of the fatty acids obtained by [Preparation of raw fatty
acids mixture 2] in Example 1 was distilled at 200°C for 120 minutes under a reduced
pressure of 5 mmHg to remove palmitic acid. Results of analysis on a composition
of the distilled fatty acids mixture are shown in table 5.
[Production of diglycerides mixture 2]
A mixture of 868 g of the distilled fatty acids obtained, 132 g of
glycerol and 50 g of an immobilized lipase (Lipozyme RM IM; Novozymes A/S) was reacted
at 50°C for 2.5 hours under a reduced pressure. After the reaction, the immobilized
lipase was separated from the reaction liquid by filtration. The reacted oil thus
obtained was subjected to molecular distillation at 230°C and 0.05 mmHg to remove
fatty acids and monoglycerides. The distilled oil obtained was acid-treated by adding
2 % by mass of a 10 % aqueous solution of citric acid and stirring at 70°C for 30
minutes under a nitrogen atmosphere followed by vacuum dehydration at 70°C. The
acid-treated oil thus obtained was then washed by adding 50 % by mass of distilled
water heated to 70°C based on the acid-treated oil and stirred well under a nitrogen
atmosphere, followed by separating an aqueous phase after leaving for standing.
This procedure was repeated twice. The resultant washed oil was then subjected to
steam deodorization at 230°C for 60 minutes under a reduced pressure to obtain a
diglycerides mixture. Results of analysis on a composition of fatty acids in the
diglycerides mixture are shown in Table 5.
Comparative Example 2[Production of triglycerides mixture 2]
A mixture of 868 g of the distilled fatty acids obtained in Comparative
Example 1, 60 g of glycerol and 50 g of an immobilized lipase obtained by immobilizing
lipase AY (Amano Enzyme Co., Ltd.) on an anion exchange resin (Duolite A-568 : ROHM
& HASS Corp.) was reacted at 40°C for 8 hours under a reduced pressure. After
the reaction, the immobilized lipase was separated from the reaction liquid by filtration.
The reacted oil thus obtained was subjected to molecular distillation at 230°C and
0.05 mmHg to remove fatty acids and monoglycerides. The resultant distilled oil
was then subjected to steam deodorization at 230°C for 60 minutes under a reduced
pressure to obtain a triglycerides mixture. Results of analysis on a composition
of fatty acids in the triglycerides mixture are shown in Table 5.
Ratio of sat'd fatty acids (C12-22)
[% by mass]Trans-acid
[% by mass]Raw fatty acids mixture (Enzymatic method)150.6Fractionated fatty acidsLiquid portion30.6Solid portion560.2Distillated fatty acids63.3Example 2 (diglycerides)32.9Example 3 (triglycerides)33.0Comp. Example (diglycerides)65.8Comp. Example (triglycerides)66.0
As apparent from Table 5, it can be understood that in a production
of a glycerides mixture from fatty acids and glycerol, use of the unsaturated fatty
acids produced by the method of the present invention gives a glycerides mixture
containing less trans-acids and less saturated fatty acids compared with that in
the case using the fatty acids produced by a distillation method.
Industrial Applicability
According to the present invention, saturated fatty acids and unsaturated
fatty acids in a raw fatty acids mixture can be easily and efficiently separated
by a dry fractionation. In addition, use of the unsaturated fatty acids thus fractionated
can provide a liquid glycerides mixture containing less trans-form of unsaturated
fatty acids at a low cost.
Anspruch[en]
A method for producing a saturated fatty acid and an unsaturated fatty acid,
which comprises adding and mixing a polyglycerol ester of a fatty acid to a raw
fatty acids mixture, cooling the resultant mixture to deposit crystals, and fractionating
the saturated fatty acid and the unsaturated fatty acid, wherein a cooling procedure
is performed at a cooling rate of 4°C/h or less when a supersaturation ratio is
60 % or more and said cooling rate is varied during the cooling.
The production method according to claim 1, wherein the cooling rate is reduced
compared to the previous rate when a supersaturation ratio becomes 60 % or more.
The production method according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the cooling is performed
while stirring.
A method for producing a glyceride by reacting an unsaturated fatty acid obtained
by fractionating by means of the production method according to any one of claims
1 to 3 with glycerol in the presence of lipase.