The present invention relates to a shoe for a hoofed animal, such
as a horseshoe, and to a method for shoeing a hoofed animal, such as a horse.
The hoof on the foot of a horse comprises a curved covering of horn
which protects the front of, and partially encloses, the end of the corresponding
digit of the horse. It thus corresponds to a nail on a finger or toe of a human
being. The forward end of the hoof is known as the toe, from which the side walls
of the hoof extend rearwardly to a heel on either side of the horse's foot. The
hoof surrounds a body of tissue which surrounds the digit itself so as to form a
capsule, the underside of which forms the sole. Between the hoof and this body of
tissue there is an intermediate layer of tissue called the white line. At the rearward
end of the horse's foot there is an elastic horny pad of generally triangular shape
which is known as the frog.
Domesticated horses are normally shod with horseshoes. A horseshoe
is usually attached by nailing to the underside of the hoof to protect it from damage.
Conventional horseshoes for horses with healthy feet are made from metal, such as
cast iron, steel, or an aluminium alloy. One common design of horseshoe is generally
arcuate in shape and sized so as to conform to the size of the hoof to be shod.
The size and weight of the horseshoe is normally determined by the type of horse
being shod. For example, a working horse will be fitted with heavier shoes than
a racehorse. In some designs there may be an upstanding tab at the front of the
shoe, or a pair of upstanding tabs positioned one to each side of the front of the
shoe, designed to assist in locating the shoe on the hoof and to provide additional
protection for the toe of the horse's foot. Other designs of metal horseshoe are
known, for example, so-called egg, straight and heart-bar shoes; these are often
recommended for use on horses with hoof or lameness problems.
The traditional way of making horseshoes is for the farrier to forge
them from bars of iron which are heated on an open hearth forge, hammered to shape
on an anvil, and pierced to provide holes for the horseshoe nails. A farrier can
produce shoes in advance for fitting to a horse with healthy feet which he has shod
previously and whose hoof measurements he already knows. Alternatively he can purchase
factory made shoes which can in suitable cases be fitted as received to a horse
with healthy feet or which may require to be modified somewhat in shape, or in the
position or direction of the holes for the horseshoe nails, using a forge and anvil.
Often the horse will be brought to the farrier's smithy to be shoed but many horses
are shod at their owner's premises, in which case the farrier will normally bring
a portable forge with him in case of need.
Plastics and rubber horseshoes are also known in the art, particularly
for shoeing horses suffering from hoof problems. See e.g. documents DE-A-2 656 348
and US-A-5 203 415. For example, rubber shoes made from a shock-absorbing rubber
bonded to a steel or aluminium core are available on the market, as are also horseshoes
made from polyurethane and from plastics moulded on to an aluminium core. Some of
these mimic the form of the conventional metal shoes and, likewise, are attached
to the hoof by nails. Another type of currently available horseshoe is sold in kit
form, using polyurethane base plates that have to be cut to the shape of the horse's
hoof. Plastics tags are then welded at intervals to the outer rim of the base in
an upwardly and radially inward fashion. The shoes are then attached to the hoof
by cementing the plastic tags to the outer wall of the hoof. Plastics horseshoes
have a number of advantages over metal shoes; for example, they are lighter and
can be affixed to a horse's hoof by glueing instead of nailing. Thus they are beneficial
for use when a horse is suffering foot problems because they obviate the use of
nails. Such foot problems may include laminitis, white line disease (or fungal onychomycosis),
navicular disease, sand cracks, or weak heels. Laminitis is a painful condition
in which the hoof becomes partly detached from the rest of the hoof capsule along
the white line. This can be accompanied by splitting of the hoof. Driving a nail
into a hoof in such a condition can exacerbate the problem besides being painful
for the horse.
In order to treat an injury to or a disease of a horse's foot, it
is usual to cut or abrade away the affected material. Since the pathogens which
attack the hoof are generally anaerobic, this helps to speed up a cure. However,
there is then the problem of providing support to the trimmed hoof so that the horse
can still put weight on its foot without undue discomfort and without exacerbating
any misalignment of the horse's leg or, in particular, of the digital bone of the
foot, due to the lameness condition from which the horse is suffering. This support
can be provided by use of a therapeutic shoe and by using a hoof replacement material
to replace the parts that have been cut or abraded away. If the farrier elects to
fit a metal shoe then he may have to undertake considerable work to forge a horseshoe
of the appropriate shape. If he decides to opt for a plastics or rubber shoe then
he may have to cut the shoe to shape or use chemicals with undesirable side effects
in order to provide a replacement for the hoof material and any tissue that has
been cut or abraded away. If the farrier decides that the horse's foot needs realignment
he may decide to provide the horseshoe with a lateral, medial, anterior or posterior
extension. This is difficult to effect with a preformed horseshoe.
Foals are sometimes born with deformities such as weak flexor tendons,
or club foot syndrome, or may require treatment to correct toe in or toe out conformation.
In such instances the farrier will often fit the foal with corrective shoes. One
type of foal corrective shoe is formed entirely from a heavy duty plastics material
with an upstanding outer cuff which is glued or cemented to the hoof wall. Such
shoes can be provided with an appropriate wedge shape and/or with an appropriate
lateral, medial, anterior or posterior extension to correct the condition being
treated. It has also been proposed to use therapeutic cuffs which can be glued or
cemented to the outer wall of the hoof after an appropriate metal shoe has been
rivetted to it or to which a shoe can be carefully nailed.
In some cases the farrier may choose to put a pad of leather or of
an elastomeric material between the hoof and the horseshoe.
European Patent Specification No. 0 893 057 A1 discloses an open plastic
horseshoe with holes for nails and having a bridge piece positioned on one arm for
adjustment of the distance between the two arms of the horseshoe.
Use for shoeing a horse of a preformed strip of L-section adhered
to a lower wall of its hoof and then adhering a plastics horseshoe thereto is proposed
in New Zealand Patent Specification No. 184321.
A horseshoe adhered to a hoof is described in New Zealand Patent Specification
No. 221274.
In German Patent Specification No. 19732269 there is taught a horseshoe
with an outer hoof cover used as the walking surface which is secured to the hoof
by at least two elements. A contact strip binding forms an intermediate layer between
the hoof surface and the outer hoof protection. The hoof protection can be made
from a thermoplastic material, such as polyester, or vinyl ester, or from an elastomer
or a metal.
International Patent Publication No. WO99/15006 describes a helical
stock from which circumferential lengths can be cut to be used as horseshoes, the
stock comprising a helical coil of plastics material wound about an axis such that
the cross section of the coil in a plane containing the axis is constant in shape
for any such plane and substantially corresponds to the cross section of a horseshoe
in the same plane.
British Patent Specification No. 2334424 teaches a horseshoe having
a metal core with a polyurethane coating.
United States Patent Specification No. 5,199,498 proposes a custom
horseshoe pad comprising a polymer composition containing at least about 50 % by
weight of high molecular caprolactone polymers wherein the composition has a melting
point of from about 120°F to about 200°F (about 48.9°C to about 93.3°C). The molecular
weight of the caprolactone polymers can range, for example, from about 35,000 to
about 60,000. The pad covers areas of the horse's foot that are sensitive and vulnerable
to disease and damage. The horseshoe pad is positioned between a horseshoe and the
hoof and is intended to expand the overall protection afforded by the standard horseshoe
without obviating the need for the shoe.
In United States Patent Specification No. 5,681,350 there is described
a rigid and permeable prosthesis that fills the debrided portion of the wall of
a horse's hoof having white line disease or the like. This prosthesis includes a
mass of particulate material with individual particles coated with a resin so as
to cleave to one another at all contact areas and transfer weight, while leaving
interconnected pore spaces that allow air and liquid medications to reach the diseased
area during the healing process.
International Patent Publication No. WO 94/06285 proposes a lightweight
plastic horseshoe which is held to the bottom of a horse's hoof by gluing it thereto
and by additionally providing preformed spaced depressions in the underside of the
hoof into which extend fasteners attached to the shoe.
In International Patent Publication No. WO 94/12024 a protective covering
for a horse's hoof is described which comprises a horseshoe made of polyurethane
having convex and concave edges and a polymeric fabric, for example a woven polyurethane
fabric, bonded to the horseshoe. The shoe is fitted to the horse's hoof and secured
thereto using an acrylic structural adhesive both between the hoof and the shoe
and between the polymeric fabric and the outside of the horse's hoof.
A horseshoe with a core of metal which is surrounded by a plastic
or rubber material and has apertures for intended for nails is suggested in International
Patent Publication No. WO 94/22296.
In International Patent Publication No. WO 95/22252 there is proposed
a method of shoeing a horse in which a particulate compound comprising a ground
up polymer and an adhesive compound. This particulate compound is poured into a
mould into which the horse's hoof, which has previously been cleaned and had an
adhesive applied to all voids, is lowered.
International Patent Publication No. WO 96/01044 is concerned with
a horseshoe having holes for horseshoe nails and including a resilient material.
Another proposal is to be found in International Patent Publication
No. WO 98/24312. This comprises a core of metal with holes for horseshoe nails which
is substantially entirely enclosed in a substantially deformable material such as
a rubber or rubber-like material.
A hoof protector for hooves of horses is suggested in International
Patent Publication No. WO 99/40782 which has a horseshoe shaped base body of plastic
and at least one fixed front setting element.
International Patent Publication No. WO 99/65298 describes a shock-absorbing
horseshoe which is secured to a horse's hoof with nails whose nailheads abut against
an intermediate resilient layer.
European Patent Specification No. 0 651 943 A1 teaches a boot for
horses' hooves made of flexible material.
A plastic covering for a horse's hoof with a two part laminate construction
for attachment to the hoof of a horse using nails is disclosed in European Patent
Specification No. 0 823 209 A2. The upper layer comprises a stable plastic material,
such as a thermally formable plastic (e.g. polyurethane, polyamide or an elastomer),
while the lower layer is less hard and is also formed from a plastic.
European Patent Specification No. 0 832 560 A1 teaches a horseshoe
which is at least partially enclosed in a resilient material which has holes for
conventional nails.
European Patent Specification No. 0 860 115 A1 discloses a horseshoe
with a shock-absorbing sole plate with a peripheral indentation for receipt of a
steel band to which are fixed six supports through which nails can be driven into
the horse's hoof.
As pointed out above most, if not all, plastics horseshoes currently
on the market suffer from the disadvantage that they are time-consuming and cumbersome
to apply, particularly those that have to be assembled from a kit of parts. This
is at least in part due to the necessity to make the horseshoe fit a damaged foot
from which a considerable amount of hoof may have been cut away. Since the horse
is lame it will usually be inconvenient or impractical for it to be brought to the
smithy so that the farrier has to take his equipment to the horse's own stable.
This tends to make it more inconvenient for the farrier to have to reshape a horseshoe
away from his own smithy.
There is accordingly a need in the art for an improved form of horseshoe
which can be used in therapy for treatment of such diseases as laminitis and which
is simple to apply to the foot of a horse being treated. There is a further need
for a novel design of horseshoe which can be readily adapted to fit and provide
support for a foot of a hoofed animal from which a variable amount of hoof material,
and possibly also other tissue, may have been cut or abraded away. There is still
further a need for a horseshoe which can be readily formed to an appropriate shape
for treatment of a horse that is suffering from foot problems, particularly when
such shaping has to be accomplished in the horse's own stable or stableyard rather
than at a farrier's smithy. Additionally there is a need for a horseshoe which can
be fitted to the hoof of a horse suffering from laminitis or other condition causing
lameness without the use of nails and in a manner which substantially avoids trauma
for the horse. Yet again there is a need for an improved method of shoeing a horse
that obviates the need to drive nails into the hoof of the horse. There is also
a need for a method of shoeing a horse suffering from a debilitating condition,
such as laminitis, which avoids trauma for the horse. Moreover there is a need to
provide a novel method of shoeing a horse which avoids the use of a forge. Another
need is for a method of shoeing a horse which utilises horseshoes which can be moulded
to a hoof and attached thereto in a simple manner without use of a forge.
The present invention accordingly seeks to provide an improved form
of horseshoe which is suitable for use in treatment of laminitis and other conditions
for which horse's feet may require treatment and which is simple to apply to the
foot of a horse being treated. It further seeks to provide a new form of horseshoe
which can be readily shaped or otherwise adapted to fit and provide support for
a foot of a hoofed animal from which hoof material, and possibly also other tissue,
has been cut or abraded away. In addition it seeks to provide a horseshoe which
can be readily formed to an appropriate shape for treatment of a horse that is suffering
from laminitis or other foot problems. It seeks moreover to provide a horseshoe
which can be formed quickly and simply to an appropriate shape even under the unfavourable
conditions which may exist in a horse's own stable or stableyard, rather than in
the convenient surroundings of the farrier's own smithy. It also seeks to provide
a plastics horseshoe that is more easily fitted to the hoof, with an improved fitting
quality and the additional support required for therapeutic purposes. Additionally
it seeks to provide a horseshoe which can be fitted to a horse's hoof without nailing
and in a manner which minimises any trauma for the animal. An additional objective
of the invention is to provide a novel and improved method of shoeing a hoofed animal,
such as a horse, without use of nails driven through the shoes into the animal's
hoof. A still further objective is to provide a novel and improved method of shoeing
a horse without causing trauma to a horse which may be suffering from a debilitating
and painful condition, such as laminitis. Yet another objective is to provide such
a method which avoids use of a forge. There is also the objective of providing a
novel and improved method of shoeing a horse which utilises horseshoes which can
be moulded to the hoof of a horse and attached thereto without requiring use of
a temperature high enough to require use of a forge.
According to one aspect of the present invention there is provided
a shoe for a hoofed animal according to claim 1.
The invention further provides a method of shoeing a hoofed animal
which comprises:
- (a) providing a shoe for a hoof of the animal, the shoe comprising a body which
is made from a thermoplastic composition which comprises a matrix of a thermoplastic
material having a softening point of less than 100°C and which has a lower ground-contacting
surface for contact, in use, with the ground and an upper foot-contacting surface
spaced from the lower ground-contacting surface for contacting, in use, the underside
of a foot of a hoofed animal, the body having around at least a part of its upper
foot-contacting surface an upstanding peripheral flange portion, and the shoe being
adapted to be fitted, in use, on an underside of the hoof with the flange portion
extending upwards from a ground border of the hoof adjacent a lower portion of an
outer horny wall of the hoof;
- (b) forming a plurality of indentations in the lower portion of the outer horny
wall of the hoof;
- (c) heating the shoe to a temperature sufficient to soften the thermoplastic
material but below its melting point;
- (d) placing the heated shoe against the underside of the hoof with its flange
portion adjacent the lower portion of the outer horny wall of the hoof; and
- (e) pressing the flange portion of the heated shoe into contact with the outer
horny wall of the hoof so as to cause material of the flange portion to enter each
of the plurality of indentations, whereby following cooling of the shoe the shoe
is retained on the hoof.
The thermoplastic material is desirably chosen so that the thermoplastic
composition is hard at ambient temperatures and at hoof sole temperatures but is
softenable by immersion in hot water, preferably boiling water or near boiling water.
In addition it should desirably possess at least moderate abrasion resistance. The
thermoplastics material preferably has a melting point or a melting point range
of less than 100°C. Even more preferably it has a freezing point of at least about
30°C, preferably at least about 35°C, and a melting point or melting point range
of less than about 95°C, more preferably less than about 90°C, and even more preferably
less than about 75°C. One particularly preferred material is a polycaprolactone.
Polycaprolactones are commercially available under the trade marks CAPA® from
Solvay Interox Limited, Baronet Road, Warrington, Cheshire WA4 6HB, United Kingdom
and TONE® from Union Carbide Corporation of 39 Old Ridgebury Road, Danbury,
Connecticut 06817-0001, United States of America. The materials sold under the trade
mark CAPA® are sold in granule form and are described as polyesters of ε-caprolactone
and butane-1,4-diol. A particular advantage of the use of a polycaprolactone is
that it is fully biodegradable. One suitable material is a polycaprolactone having
a freezing point of about 35°C, and a melting point range of from about 58°C to
about 60°C. Such a material has a molecular weight of from about 48,000 Daltons
to about 52,000 Daltons and is sold under the trade designation CAPA® 650 polycaprolactone.
It is also possible to blend CAPA® 650 polycaprolactone with minor amounts,
for example up to about 25% by weight or more, e.g. up to about 40% by weight, of
another polycaprolactone such as CAPA® 680 polycaprolactone and/or with lesser
amounts, for example up to about 10% by weight, of CAPA® 640 polycaprolactone.
CAPA® 680 polycaprolactone is reported to have a melting point of about 60 to
62°C and a molecular weight of about 80,000 Daltons, while CAPA® 640 polycaprolactone
is reported to have a melting point of from 58 to 60°C and a molecular weight of
about 37,000 Daltons. A particularly preferred thermoplastic material comprises
a mixture of about 2 parts by weight of CAPA® 650 polycaprolactone and about
1 part by weight of CAPA® 680 polycaprolactone.
A preferred form of shoe according to the invention comprises a body
moulded from a thermoplastic composition which comprises a matrix of a thermoplastic
material having a freezing point of at least about 30°C and a melting point or melting
point range of less than about 95°C, the body having a lower ground-contacting surface
for contact, in use, with the ground and an upper foot-contacting surface spaced
from the lower ground-contacting surface for contacting, in use, the underside of
a foot of a hoofed animal, such as a horse, the body having around at least a part
of its upper foot-contacting surface an upstanding peripheral flange portion adapted
in use to abut against at least a part of the outer wall of the foot of a horse
or other hoofed animal. In such a shoe intended for use on a horse, the body may
comprise an arcuate bar portion shaped to underlie the hoof. In addition the two
ends of the bar portion may be joined one to another by a crosspiece. Moreover the
shoe may include a frogpiece intended to underlie the frog of the horse's foot and
which may be provided with a cut out portion that extends from the rearward end
of the frogpiece part way towards the front end of the frogpiece so as to facilitate
flexing of the shoe. If desired, the flange portion may include an upstanding rear
flange portion adapted to abut against the heels of the hoof. Such a shoe can be
moulded as a one piece moulding. It can have a chamfered portion on its underside
at its front end which underlies the toe of the horse's hoof, in use. Otherwise
the under surface of the shoe may be substantially planar.
The flange portion may be continuous or discontinuous. It may be adapted
so as to extend, in use, from one side wall around the toe of the horse's hoof to
the other side wall. Alternatively the flange portion may be adapted to extend,
in use, from the toe of the horse's hoof back towards each of the heels thereof
a distance which is less than the overall peripheral distance from the toe to the
heel. Instead of a continuous flange portion it is possible ) to utilise a plurality
of tab portions or to use a flange portion whose height varies along its length,
such as a crenellated flange portion.
The flange portion may taper in section from its root towards its
upper free rim portion. Thus, for example, it may taper in section from a thickness
of about 5 mm at its root to about 3 mm at its upper free rim. Typically the body
is about 10 mm deep and the flange portion extends upwards for about 20 mm, making
the overall height of the horseshoe about 30 mm. It can be made in a variety of
sizes. For example, it may measure about 125 mm from front to back and about 105
mm across. However, larger sizes, e.g. for carthorses, or smaller sizes, e.g. for
use in correction of foal's foot deformities, can be produced in accordance with
the teachings of the invention.
In use of a horseshoe of the invention, the farrier typically first
removes any hoof and tissue that may be damaged. Then the horse's hoof can be treated
by rasping a number of horizontal key-in lines around the bottom 2 to 3 cm or so
of the outer wall. The wall of the hoof is then cleaned with acetone or, preferably,
surgical spirit, prior to which the farrier should don protective gloves. Latex
gloves are suitable. A horseshoe of the appropriate size according to the invention
is then selected and the toe can, if necessary, be worked to create a bevelled edge
at the front of the shoe, sloping in an upwardly outward direction from the underside,
to provide a larger ground bearing surface area and to facilitate clearance of the
toe of the hoof over the ground, thereby reducing the risk of the horse jarring
its infected foot. This process can alternatively be performed after the horseshoe
has been fitted.
The horseshoe is then placed into a non-reactive liquid, e.g. water,
which has been raised to a temperature greater than the freezing point of the thermoplastic
material and preferably above its softening point or softening point range. Hence
the temperature of the water or other liquid is preferably at least about 60°C and
preferably at least about 80°C. In practice it has been found that a bucket filled
with boiling or near boiling water will retain sufficient heat to enable fitting
of at least one horseshoe to be completed. The thermoplastic material remains in
the liquid until it becomes soft and pliable. This is characterised by the flange
of the horseshoe turning transparent. The horseshoe is removed from the liquid before
the entire mass turns transparent so as to ensure that it retains its form. This
usually takes less than 2 minutes, e.g. about 90 seconds, depending upon the size
of the shoe, the temperature of the water and the material used.
Alternatively some other means of heating the thermoplastic material
can be used, such as a blow torch or hot air blower. However, the use of hot water
has the advantage that it reduces the tackiness of the softened horseshoe and hence
of it sticking to the farrier's gloves or other objects with which it may come in
contact.
When the horseshoe has softened sufficiently to become manually deformable,
the horseshoe is then fitted to the horse's foot by pressing the softened shoe firmly
onto the hoof thereby deforming the upper surface of the horseshoe to fit the horse's
foot and by pressing the flange portion against the outer surface of the hoof horn
outer wall. It is preferable to apply the softened horseshoe heel end first, using
the frog as a datum. Special care should be taken to ensure that the shoe is moulded
tightly round the hoof. The flange is arranged such that it is in continuous contact
with the wall of the hoof around at least a part of its circumference. The flange
may extend towards each heel of the hoof only a part of the overall distance from
the toe to the heel of the hoof. In this case the heel is free to flex somewhat
in use as the horse moves. Alternatively the flange portion can extend substantially
the entire distance from the toe of the hoof to its heel on each side of the hoof.
In this case the flange portion can be bonded to the hoof, or what remains of it,
around the entire periphery of the hoof from one heel to the other. Moreover it
can in this latter case also continue across the rear of the horseshoe so that it
extends across the rear of the horse's foot.
Each horseshoe can thus be moulded so as to be custom made to match
the unique features of each hoof. In addition, if the farrier wishes to build up
the horseshoe at any point it is a simple matter to soften some additional polycaprolactone
material and then, after cleaning the hoof if necessary, to press the additional
material on the softened shoe in the appropriate place.
When the shoe has been satisfactorily shaped to the horse's hoof a
rapid coolant can be applied which causes the thermoplastic to re-solidify. Suitable
coolants are sold in aerosol dispensers for use in plumbing. A suitable coolant
is available from Poynton Ltd, of 60 High Street, Malmesbury, Wiltshire SN16 9AT
under the trade mark IMPRINT™. This product is described by its suppliers
as a self-propelling mixture of not more than 10% dimethyl ether and the balance
1,1,1,2-tetrafluoroethylene. Resolidification of the horseshoe is characterised
by the horseshoe becoming opaque again as it hardens.
The shoe can be cemented to the hoof by application of a suitable
bonding agent between the flange of the horseshoe and the hoof. Suitable bonding
agents include those sold under the trade marks Equithane™ and Bond-N-Flex™.
A particularly preferred bonding agent is that available under the trade mark IMPRINT™
from Poynton Ltd, of 60 High Street, Malmesbury, Wiltshire SN16 9AT, which is described
as a two-part methacrylate adhesive whose components comprise not more than 55%
by weight methyl methacrylate and not more than 8% by weight methacrylic acid. The
bonding agent can be applied between the flange portion over its entire length.
Hence, in one form of horseshoe, bonding agent can be applied over the entire periphery
of the hoof, from heel to heel, such that the bonding agent is lipping the top of
the flange. In other designs, however, the flange portion does not extend back as
far as the heels so that it is adhered to the hoof, or what remains of it, only
over a part of the entire periphery of the hoof. Application of the bonding agent
can be achieved by prising the edge of the flange away from the hoof wall and injecting
the bonding agent into the cavity.
Alternatively and more usually a bonding agent can be applied to the
flange portion of the softened horseshoe and normally also to the hoof horn outer
wall against which the flange portion is to abut before the horseshoe is applied
to the horse's hoof.
It is an advantage of the IMPRINT™ bonding agent that it can
be applied to the softened horseshoe immediately after it has been taken out of
hot water, even though it is still wet.
It will usually be advantageous to warm the bonding agent somewhat
prior to application so as to speed up curing thereof. The horizontal key-in lines
rasped into the wall of the hoof improve the grip of the bonding agent on the wall.
Attaching the horseshoe to the hoof in this way prevents the damage caused by nailing
the shoe in place.
Any final adjustments can then be made to ensure a comfortable fit
for the horse.
It is to be understood that the present invention is not restricted
to shoes for horses but includes shoes for any hoofed animal. Hence the teachings
of the invention can be applied with equal success to shoes for such hoofed animals
as donkeys, mules, zebras, and cows.
The thermoplastic composition may further comprise a minor amount
(e.g. from about 1% by volume up to about 25% by volume) of a filler material, such
as a dye or a rubber in crumb, chunk, or granule form.
If desired, the underside of the shoe can be provided with one or
more rubber inserts therein.
In order that the invention may be clearly understood and readily
carried into effect some preferred embodiments thereof will now be described, by
way of example only, with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:
- Figure 1 is a bottom view of a horseshoe according to the invention;
- Figure 2 is a longitudinal side view of the horseshoe of Figure 1;
- Figure 3 is a rear view of the horseshoe of Figures 1 and 2;
- Figure 4 is a bottom view of a larger horseshoe than that of Figures 1 to 3
according to the invention;
- Figure 5 is a bottom view of a smaller horseshoe than that of Figures 1 to 3
according to the invention;
- Figure 6 is a bottom view of a further modified form of horseshoe according
to the invention;
- Figure 7 is a side view of the horseshoe of Figure 6; Figure 8 is a rear view
of the horseshoe of Figures 6 and 7;
- Figure 9 is a side view of a horse's hoof illustrating a first step in shoeing
a horse using the method of the present invention;
- Figure 10 is a solar view of the hoof of Figure 9;
- Figure 11 is a further side view of the hoof of Figures 9 and 10 showing a later
stage in the method of the invention with a horseshoe according to the invention
in place on the horse's hoof;
- Figure 12 is a solar view of the hoof of Figure 11 with its attached shoe;
- Figure 13 is a sagittal section through the hoof of Figures 9 and 10;
- Figure 14 is a similar sagittal section through the hoof of Figures 11 and 12;
- Figure 15 illustrates diagrammatically sagittal sections through a horse's hoof
showing various possible types of indentation;
- Figure 16 is a side view of a horse's hoof showing diagrammatically various
possible shapes of indentation;
- Figure 17 is a top plan view of a further form of horseshoe constructed in accordance
with the invention; and
- Figure 18 is a bottom plan view of the horseshoe of Figure 17.
Referring to Figures 1 to 3 of the drawings, a horseshoe 1 of the
heartbar type is moulded in one piece from CAPA® 650 polycaprolactone, which
is available from Solvay Interox Limited, Baronet Road, Warrington, Cheshire WA4
6HB, United Kingdom. It can be made from the polycaprolactone by any suitable technique.
As examples of moulding techniques there can be mentioned casting and injection
moulding. It is also possible to heat polycaprolactone granules in a vessel containing
water until the granules coalesce to form a gel, to mould the resulting gel with
the fingers into a sausage-like shape, to place the sausage-like shape in a female
part of a mould, and then to close the mould with a male member and apply a weight
to the male member to cause the material of the sausage-like shape to conform to
the shape of the mould cavity. The length of horseshoe 1 is about 125 mm and its
breadth is about 105 mm.
The horseshoe 1 comprises a body 2 having a lower ground-contacting
surface 3 and an upper foot-contacting surface 4 spaced from the lower ground-contacting
surface. Around at least a part of the upper foot-contacting surface 4 of the body
2 there is an upstanding peripheral flange portion 5 which is adapted in use to
abut against at least a part of the outer wall of the foot of a horse (not shown).
Horseshoe 1 is generally substantially part oval and approximately conforms to the
periphery of the hoof. The flange portion 5 protects the lower part of the hoof
and provides a means of attaching the horseshoe 1 to the hoof other than by nailing.
As can be seen from Figure 1, horseshoe 1 comprises an arcuate bar
portion 6 shaped to underlie the hoof. Moreover the two ends of the bar portion
6 are joined one to another at the rear of the horseshoe 1 by a crosspiece 7. Crosspiece
7 further carries a frogpiece 8 intended to underlie the frog of the horse's foot.
The rear ends of flange portion 5 are joined by an upstanding rear flange portion
9 which is formed on the upper side of the crosspiece 7 and which is intended to
abut against the heels of the hoof. Rear flange portion 9 is lower than flange portion
5. A chamfered portion 10 is formed on its underside at its front end so as to underlie
the toe of the horse's hoof, in use. The flange portion 5 extends, in use, from
a heel of one side wall of the hoof around the toe of the hoof to a heel of the
other side wall.
Body 2 is approximately 10 mm thick and the height of the flange portion
5 above upper surface 4 is approximately 20 mm, making the overall height of the
horseshoe approximately 30 mm. Flange portion 5 tapers in section from its root,
where its thickness is about 5 mm, to approximately 3 mm at its upper rim. It is,
however, to be understood that these are only approximate dimensions and the invention
allows for substantial variations to fit a wide range of horses' hooves.
As already mentioned, the toe of the shoe is provided with a bevelled
portion 10 which slopes upwardly from the undersurface 3.
In use of the horseshoe of Figures 1 to 3 for treatment of a horse
suffering from laminitis or some other condition adversely affecting the horse's
foot, the farrier prepares the horse's hoof prior to fitting, in so doing trimming
away any hoof material, and possibly also other tissue, that has been affected by
the hoof condition. The edge of the ground bearing surface, i.e. the undersurface,
of the hoof is bevelled and a number of horizontal key-in lines are rasped into
the bottom 2 cm to 3 cm or so of the hoof. The horizontal lines are used to increase
the purchase of the bonding agent which is subsequently used to secure the horseshoe
1 on the hoof, which is otherwise relatively smooth. The toe of the shoe 1 is then,
if necessary, further bevelled as required and the hoof is cleaned with acetone
or surgical spirit. For the purposes of heating the horseshoe 1 the preferred method
is to submerge the shoe in boiling, or close to boiling, water until the thermoplastic
material becomes sufficiently pliable for application to the hoof, which is indicated
by the flange portion 5 turning from opaque to transparent. This typically takes
between about 30 seconds and about 2 minutes for horseshoes made out of CAPA®
650 polycaprolactone, depending upon the size of the shoe 1 and the temperature
of the water. However, the horseshoe 1 should not be left in the hot water until
it becomes wholly clear in appearance since it will then lose its form entirely.
When the horseshoe 1 is ready to be fitted, it is removed from the
water and applied to the hoof. The preferred method of application of the horseshoe
1 to the hoof is to fit the heel first, using the frog as a datum, and forming the
softened horseshoe 1 into the contours of the hoof. Particular attention should
be paid to shaping the flange portion 5 around the hoof to ensure that it is in
contact with the hoof around its full periphery. Attention should also be given
to the shaping of the rear flange portion 9 to ensure that it conforms to the shape
of the heel. This produces a custom horseshoe for the particular hoof to which it
is fitted. The horseshoe 1 is then rapidly cooled to set the thermoplastic material
again. This can be achieved by using an aerosol coolant which is sprayed onto the
horseshoe 1. To avoid startling the horse by the noise made by the coolant escaping
from the aerosol can the farrier can talk, whistle or croon to the horse. Alternatively
a pad of foamed plastics material can be placed around the hoof and the coolant
sprayed directly into the foam which deadens the sound made by the escaping coolant.
The horseshoe 1 turns opaque again when hard.
A bonding agent can then be applied to cement the horseshoe 1 to the
hoof. Preferred bonding agents include those sold under the trade marks Equithane™
and Bond-N-Flex™ or IMPRINT™. Preferably the bonding agent is preheated
in hot water before being injected between the flange portion 5 and the hoof. A
pointed instrument can be used as necessary to prise a gap between the flange portion
5 and hoof so as to allow the bonding agent to flow between them. The bonding agent
is injected around the entire periphery of the hoof. Sufficient of the bonding agent
is used such that it fills the cavity between flange portion 5 and the hoof to the
top of flange portion 5. The bonding agent usually sets within 10 minutes. After
the bonding agent has set, final adjustments can be made to the horseshoe 1 to ensure
a comfortable fit for the horse.
If desired, tungsten studs or other non-slip grip-enhancing devices
can be inserted in the horseshoe. This can be done by heating a sharp tool in hot
water and pushing its point carefully into the underside of the horseshoe 1 after
it has been fitted to the horse and then inserting a tungsten stud into the resulting
blind hole whilst its walls are still soft and spraying on a coolant to re-freeze
the polycaprolactone material.
Another way to impart non-slip properties to the horseshoe of the
invention is to incorporate at least one rubber insert in the under surface of the
horseshoe. Such an insert may take the form of a rubber strip, a rubber chunk, or
rubber crumbs or granules. More than one rubber insert can be provided, particularly
if rubber chunks, crumbs or granules are used. The at least one rubber insert is
positioned in the horseshoe so as to form part of the ground-contacting surface
of the horseshoe. If a strip of vulcanised rubber is used, then its dimensions are
preferably chosen such that its length is less than the arcuate distance measured
around the horseshoe from one heel thereof to the other, and is preferably no more
than about 80% of this arcuate distance, such that its width is less than the width
of the arcuate portion of the horseshoe, and is preferably no more than about 60%
of such width, and such that its thickness is not more than about 60% of the overall
thickness of that part of the horseshoe that is adapted in use to underlie the hoof
of the horse. Moreover it is preferred that the strip is trapezoidal in section
with the longer of the two parallel sides of the trapezium being disposed uppermost
in the horseshoe. The difference in length between the two parallel sides of the
trapezium need be no more than about 2 mm, and is preferably no more than about
1 mm to about 1.5 mm. A suitable strip is about 8 mm wide on its underside and about
6 mm thick and of appropriate length to suit the size of the horseshoe. If such
a rubber strip is placed in the mould prior to casting of the polycaprolactone material
or other thermoplastic material, then it becomes permanently embedded in the horseshoe
and is retained therein by reason of its shape. Preferably the rubber strip is shaped
so as to be arcuate in plan, although it can be a straight strip appropriately bent
to shape. To facilitate correct placement of the rubber strip, an arcuate groove
can be formed in the bottom of the mould. The use of such a groove in the bottom
of the mould will further ensure that the underside of the rubber strip projects
below the polycaprolactone mass from which the major part of the horseshoe is formed.
Suitably the rubber strip projects about 2 mm below the underside of the horseshoe.
As suitable rubbers there can be mentioned any non-slip abrasion resistant rubber
material, for example any of those natural or synthetic rubbers which are conventionally
used for the manufacture of motor vehicle tyres or of rubber soles or heels for
men's or ladies' shoes. Besides imparting non-slip properties to the horseshoe the
rubber insert may perform other functions, for example as a surface upon which to
display a trade mark. For this purpose the rubber insert may have, for example,
a triangular shape which is positioned to underlie a frog part of the horseshoe
and to display a trade mark such as IMPRINT™. In order to ensure retention
of a triangular or other shape of insert in the finished horseshoe, it is preferred
that the dimensions of the upper side of the insert are at least slightly larger
than those of the underside thereof, for example about 1 mm to about 2 mm larger.
When chunks, crumbs or granules of rubber are used these can be scattered on the
bottom of the mould before casting of the polycaprolactone material or other thermoplastic
material takes place. The chunks, crumbs or granules of rubber in this case should
have a maximum dimension of no more than about 5 mm, and preferably no more than
about 2 mm or 3 mm. After casting of the polycaprolactone material, the rubber chunks,
crumbs or granules form at least a part of the under surface of the horseshoe and,
provided that sufficient rubber chunks, crumbs or granules have been used, impart
non-slip properties thereto after casting of the polycaprolactone material or other
thermoplastic material has occurred.
The farrier may decide during the preliminary work on the horse's
hoof and before the bonding agent is applied that the fit of the horseshoe needs
to be improved, for example to provide support where hoof and/or tissue has ben
removed. In this case he can clean the horseshoe and then can build up the upper
surface of the shoe by softening some additional polycaprolactone, possibly having
also reheated the horseshoe, and moulding the additional polycaprolactone in place
to provide the correct support for the horse's foot. This can be achieved very quickly.
In a modification of the horseshoe of Figures 1 to 3, the flange portion
5 is arranged to extend part of the way only, for example from about one half to
two thirds of the way only, from the toe to the heel along each side of the horseshoe.
Upon bonding such a horseshoe to a horse's hoof, the result is that the heels of
the hoof can still flex with respect to the rest of the horse's foot.
It will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that the use of
a horseshoe in accordance with the invention radically alters the traditional methods
of farriery in that the farrier can use a bucket of hot water to soften a plastics
material to shape the horseshoe in the way that the treatment of the horse requires
instead of having to use the traditional forge and anvil or having to trim or assemble
a plastics horseshoe from a kit of parts. Such a new method of shoeing a horse can
be carried out easily and quickly wherever the horse happens to be stabled without
having to transport the horse to the farrier's smithy. Moreover shoeing can be effected
with minimum trauma being caused to the horse.
In place of CAPA® 650 polycaprolactone it is alternatively possible
to utilise a mixture of CAPA® 650 polycaprolactone with one or both of CAPA®
680 caprolactone and CAPA® 640 polycaprolactone. Such mixtures include, for
example, an 80:20 or an 83:17 mixture by weight of CAPA® 650 and CAPA® 680
polycaprolactones. In some cases it may also be beneficial to admix a small quantity,
for example up to about 10% by weight of CAPA® 640 polycaprolactone with CAPA®
650 polycaprolactone or with a CAPA® 650/CAPA® 680 polycaprolactone mixture.
Figures 4 and 5 show respectively a larger horseshoe 11 and a smaller
horseshoe 12 which are generally similar to the horseshoe 1 of Figures 1 to 3.
Figures 6 to 8 illustrate a modified form of horseshoe 21 which is
generally similar to that of Figures 1 to 3 but in which the flange portion 25 extends
from the front of the horseshoe 21, which will underlie the toe of the horse's hoof,
in use, backwards along each side only a part of the overall distance towards the
part of the horseshoe which will underlie the respective heel of the horse's hoof
in use. In addition there is no flange on horseshoe 21 corresponding to the rear
flange portion 9 of the horseshoe 1 of Figures 1 to 3 so that the horseshoe 21 is
open at the back. When horseshoe 21 is fitted to a horse's foot, using the same
general technique as described above, the flange portion 25 enables it to be firmly
attached to the toe and front part of the hoof but the design of the horseshoe 21
allows the heels to flex and to move relative to the horseshoe 21.
Although the invention has been illustrated with reference to horseshoes
with a crosspiece and a frogpiece, it will be understood by those skilled in the
art that many alternative designs of horseshoe incorporating the teachings of the
invention can be made. Examples include horseshoes of the so-called egg, egg-heartbar,
square toed heartbar, and straightbar types. The invention is also applicable to
the production of foal correction boots, as well as to horseshoes with soles, with
graduation, or with medial, lateral, anterior or posterior extensions.
Figures 9 to 16 illustrate a preferred method in accordance with the
invention of shoeing a hoofed animal, such as a horse.
Figure 9 is a side view of a horse's hoof 100 having a number of indentations
101 that have been made by a farrier in the outer horny wall of the hoof 100 in
readiness for attachment of a horseshoe in accordance with the invention. Indentations
101 can be formed by any convenient method, for example using a router tool, a knife,
such as a loop knife, or a farrier's instrument for removing horn from a horse's
hoof. Preferably, however, a router tool is used to make indentations 101. These
indentations are made in a lower portion of the hoof which extends from a ground
border 102 of the hoof 100 upwards a distance of from about 1 cm to about 2 cm.
The shape and size of indentations 101 are discussed further below. Typically the
farrier should make from five to ten indentations 101 substantially regularly spaced
apart from each other in the lower portion of the hoof horn outer surface, usually
from six to eight indentations 101 being an adequate number.
After or before forming indentations 101 in hoof 100 the farrier also
preferably bevels the lower edge of the horny outer wall, conveniently by use of
a rasp or file, so as to provide a bevelled edge 103 around the front part of the
ground border 102 of hoof 100. Also visible in Figure 10 are the sole 104, the frog
105 and the heels 106 of hoof 100.
Figure 11 illustrates the hoof 100 after the next stage of the process
of the invention, namely fitting of a horseshoe 21 (see Figures 6 to 8). During
this step and the succeeding steps the farrier is advised to wear latex gloves.
Before fitting of the horseshoe 21 to the hoof 100, the farrier should
first clean the outer wall of the hoof 100 with a solvent for grease, such as surgical
spirit or acetone. As described above, the horseshoe 21 is first softened by immersion
in hot water in the temperature range of from about 65°C to about 100°C, preferably
near boiling, i.e. at least about 90°C, until its flange portion 25 becomes transparent.
(The horseshoe 21 should not be left in the hot water until it becomes completely
transparent or it will lose all of its form). The horseshoe 21 should then be removed
carefully from the water and any excess water allowed to drain off. A bead of IMPRINT™
bonding agent can then be applied to the inside of the flange portion 25, even though
it is still wet; a further bead of IMPRINT™ bonding agent is preferably also
applied around a corresponding portion of the outer surface of the hoof horn outer
wall. While its flange portion 25 is still pliable the horseshoe 21 is then applied
to the underside of the hoof 100. In so doing the farrier should fit the horseshoe
21 first at the heels 106 end of the hoof 100, using the frog 105 as a datum, and
then press the shoe 21 onto the hoof 100 so as to help conform the upper face of
horseshoe 21 to the shape of the underside of hoof 100. While the flange portion
25 remains manually mouldable, the farrier should then mould this to the outer surface
of the hoof horn outer wall. In this moulding operation the farrier should apply
pressure with his fingers to the outer surface of the flange portion 25 in the region
of each of the indentations 101 so as to press material of the flange portion 25
into each of the indentations 101. During this moulding operation care should be
taken not to cause over-thinning of any significant part of the flange portion 25.
Figure 12 shows the underside of hoof 100 with the horseshoe 21 applied
thereto. Reference numeral 104 indicates the sole of the hoof 100.
In Figure 13 there is shown a sagittal section through hoof 100 after
formation of an indentation 101 and before application of a horseshoe 21. As can
be seen from Figure 13 indentation 101 has a bulb-like section. Conveniently it
is formed using a router tool in the hoof horn outer wall 107. Its depth is preferably
from about 1 mm up to about 80% of the thickness of the hoof horn outer wall 107,
while its maximum transverse dimension at the surface of the hoof horn outer wall
107 is typically from about 2 mm up to about 10 mm.
Figure 14 is a similar sagittal view of hoof 100 after moulding of
the flange portion 25 to the hoof horn outer wall 107 and shows how some of the
material of the flange portion 25 has been pressed into the indentation 101, as
indicated by reference numeral 108.
In Figures 13 and 14 there are also shown the laminae 109, the bone
110, the corium 111, and the white line 112.
Once the farrier is satisfied with the moulding operation and with
the resulting shoe balance, re-hardening of the material of the horseshoe 21 can
be accelerated by use of a refrigerant spray directed on the horseshoe 21 from an
aerosol spray can. Upon such re-hardening the horseshoe 21 again becomes opaque
and the hoof 100 can be placed on the ground again. There is now union between the
hoof 100 and horseshoe 21, with the latter being attached firmly to the hoof 100
without movement.
In order to further improve this union, a bonding agent, such as a
two part adhesive, for example, a urethane polymer adhesive, can be applied from
a twin cartridge pack fitted with a mixer nozzle for the two components. Preferably
the pack is preheated by immersion in hot water so as to accelerate subsequent cure
thereof. As already mentioned, the bonding agent can be applied to the flange portion
25 while it is still softened. Alternatively, but less preferably, the bonding agent
can be applied along the length of the upper edge of the flange portion 25 and lipping
the join between the flange portion 25 and the hoof horn outer wall. A pointed instrument
can be used during this operation in order to ply the upper edge of flange portion
25 away from the hoof horn outer wall. Once the farrier is satisfied that the bonding
agent has been uniformly applied all along the upper edge of flange portion 25,
a spatula can be used to smooth the surface of the resulting joint. The horse should
then be encouraged to stand as still as possible until the bonding agent has hardened,
normally about 10 to about 15 minutes. Complete hardening of the bonding agent will
typically take approximately an hour.
If during the course of the fitting of the horseshoe 21 to hoof 100
the farrier should want to remould the already hardened flange portion 25, this
can readily be achieved by directing hot air from a hot air gun against the appropriate
part of the outer surface of flange portion 25. During such a procedure the hot
air gun should be pointing downward and away from the limb. To avoid misdirecting
the hot air onto any part of the horse's leg other than the hoof, it is advisable
for the farrier to place his hand around the coronary border 113 of hoof 100. Having
re-softened the flange portion 25 in this way, the farrier can soften first the
flange portion 25 along one side of hoof 100 and peel it away from the hoof horn
outer wall, before treating the flange portion 25 along the other side of the hoof
in a similar way. The flange portion 25 can then be re-moulded to the hoof 100.
The indentations 101 in Figures 9 and 11 are substantially elliptical
in plan and are, as shown in Figures 13 and 14, bulb-shaped in section. Figures
15 and 16 illustrate alternative shapes for indentations, in plan and in section
respectively. It should, however, be noted that only the lowermost indentation in
Figure 15 lies on the lower portion of the hoof horn outer surface. The other forms
of indentation are shown at high locations than would be used in actual practice,
solely for convenience and to avoid proliferation of Figures. Hence any of the forms
of indentation illustrated would, in practice, be positioned at a height above the
ground border 102 similar to that indicated for indentations 101 in Figures 9 and
11. Indentation 114 has a rectangular section, indentation 115 has a square one,
indentation 116 has a V section, indentation 117 has a triangulation section, indentation
118 a U-shaped section, indentation 119 a bulb section (like the section of indentation
101 of Figure 13) section, and indentation 120 has a semi-circular section.
In Figure 16 indentation 121 has an elliptical or oval configuration
in plan, indentation 122 has a round one, indentation 123 has a rectangular configuration,
indentation 124 has a square one, and indentation 125 has a triangular configuration
in plan.
It will be appreciated by those skilled in farriery that the method
described in relation to Figures 9 to 16 is an improvement upon shoeing a horse
with a tender or diseased hoof with a conventional metal shoe since it involves
no nailing and requires the use of low temperatures only. Thus the farrier does
not need to apply a hot shoe to a tender hoof with a resulting lack of trauma for
the horse. Since the shoe is applied to the hoof in softened form, it can be moulded
in situ to a certain extent to fit the particular hoof to which it is being applied,
thereby ensuring a more comfortable fit for the horse. Moreover because no hammering
is required there is a greatly reduced risk of causing pain to a lame horse. The
procedure for heating and fitting a shoe in accordance with the invention is quick
and so the time for which the animal has to stand on three legs only is reduced.
This can be a very relevant consideration when the horse is lame.
It will be appreciated by skilled farriers that the horseshoes of
the invention have advantages over conventional metal horseshoes even for shoeing
horses that have healthy hooves and that are not lame. Thus their lightness compared
to metal horseshoes can be advantageous when shoeing racehorses.
Figures 17 and 18 illustrate a further form of horseshoe 201 which
is generally similar to shoe 21 of Figures 6 to 8 except that a cut out portion
202 is formed in the frogpiece 203. This cut out portion imparts a certain degree
of flexibility to horseshoe 201 and allows limited relative vertical movement of
the heels 204 and 205. Reference numeral 206 indicates the flange portion around
the toe of the horseshoe 201, which is similar to flange 25 of horseshoe 21 of Figures
6 to 8, while reference numeral 207 indicates a chamfered portion at the toe end
of the horseshoe 201.
If desired, a minor chamfered surface can also be provided on the
upper face of horseshoe 201 adjacent the inner arcuate edge 208. This chamfered
surface can make an angle of about 15° with the remainder of the upper surface of
the horseshoe 201 within the flange portion 206. A similar minor chamfered surface
can be provided, if desired, on any of the other illustrated embodiments of the
invention.