The invention relates to a new process for producing granules of a
phosphorus doped activated alumina, the granules themselves and the use of the granules
as a growth regulator, especially as low phosphorus buffer in potted plants. Here
and in the following, "phosphorus" always means pentavalent inorganic phosphorus
(Pv), e. g., phosphate.
Chemical growth regulation is widely used in conventional horticultural
production systems to produce flowering potted plants with e. g. desired height
and shape. Most of the species produced as potted plants require growth regulation
in order to become a saleable product. Restrictions against the use of chemical
growth regulators due to environmental concerns set up pressure to find alternative
ways of plant growth regulation.
A method of fertilising plants with phosphorus charged on alumina,
the phosphorus being slowly desorbed and made available for plant uptake is disclosed
in US-A 5 693 119. The phosphorus source is an acid treated activated alumina which
is obtained after contacting an active alumina with an aqueous solution of potassium
dihydrogenphosphate for three days and after two days of drying at a relatively
low temperature. This process was found too laborious for large scale production.
On the other hand it was determined that the drying lead to some loss of activity.
Furthermore, the (hydrochloric) acid treatment results in a considerable chloride
content of the resulting P buffer which is undesirable as many plant species are
chloride-sensitive.
In order to successfully use phosphorus buffers for sufficient growth
regulation a strict control of phosphorus desorption is extremely important. Plants
need to be grown under moderate and controlled phosphorus deficiency for sufficient
growth regulation, and any loss of buffer activiy may result in undesirably low
phosphorus concentration in the growth media and may cause deleterious phosphorus
starvation.
Phosphorus doped alumina produced according to US-A 5 693 119 does
not desorb the phosphorus in such a precisely controllable manner which would be
necessary for controlled phosphorus deficiency and optimal growth regulation. It
has also been found that this doped alumina contains a large amount of moisture
(as determined at 300 °C), usually more than 10%.
One object of the invention therefore is to produce a phosphorus doped
activated alumina which does not incur the drawbacks known in the art. A further
object of the invention is to provide an improved and environment-friendly growth
regulator, especially a low P-buffer for potted plants.
It was found that phosphorus doped activated alumina produced following
the procedure of claim 1 surprisingly showed excellent properties as growth regulator,
especially as a low P-buffer in potted plants.
According to claim 1 the process comprises the steps of
- a) compacting a mixture of an aluminium hydroxide and a phosphorus source
- b) size reducing the compacted material and
- c) activating the size reduced material at a temperature of at least 300 °C,
preferably 350 °C to 600 °C, and, optionally,
- d) classifying the granules obtained by steps a) - c).
Here and in the following, the term "aluminium hydroxide" comprises
both Al(OH)3 and AIOOH. The aluminium hydroxides suitable as starting
material for the process of the invention usually are commercially available aluminium
hydroxides obtained from the Bayer process, such as aluminium hydroxides of the
MARTINAL® type of Alusuisse Martinswerk, Bergheim, Germany.
Though not preferred, a pseudoboehmite of the formula AIOOH or mixtures
thereof with aluminium hydroxide may also be used as starting material.
The grain size of a suitable Bayer aluminium hydroxide is as a rule
such that 95 wt.% of the material does not exceed 200 µm in grain diameter. The
d50 value preferably ranges between 30 µm and 150 µm.
The specific surface area (according to BET) of the starting material
is not critical but as a rule is usually 5 m2/g or less.
The Na2Ototal content is expediently chosen lower than 0.5
wt.% referring to Al2O3.
In order to guarantee a satisfactory compaction process the moisture content is,
depending on the grain size, preferably held below 2.0 %.
The phosphorus source is expediently selected from phosphoric acid,
salts derived from phosphoric acid or mixtures thereof. Alternatively also mineral
phosphates (i. e., naturally occuring phosphates) or salts derived from mineral
phosphates like calcium phosphates or ammonium phosphates can be used.
Suitable salts derived from phosphoric acid can e. g. be selected
from phosphates, monohydrogenphosphates or dihydrogenphosphates of potassium, magnesium
and/or calcium, which may be supplemented by micronutrients such as zinc, iron and
copper.
Expediently mixtures of phosphoric acid and a phosphate, monohydrogenphosphate
or dihydrogenphosphate of potassium, magnesium and/or calcium and, optionally, zinc,
iron or copper are applied.
As a rule phosphoric acid also functions as a preferable pH adjustment
source. However a pH adjustment can also be achieved with other mineral acids like
hydrochloric acid or sulfuric acid, although not preferred due to the decomposition
and formation of toxic gases during the activation treatment or the resulting chloride
content.
The cations mentioned also play an important role as nutrient elements.
They can not only be provided in the form of the respective phosphate salt but also
(additionally) in the form of other common salts like e. g. sulfates or nitrates.
In the mixture containing phosphoric acid and salt(s) derived from
phosphoric acid the ratio of phosphoric acid to salt(s) derived from phosphoric
acid is preferably 1:0.3 to 1:20.
However also a loading with 100% phosphoric acid or 100% salt derived from phosphoric
acid is possible.
Particularly good results have been obtained with mixtures of phosphoric
acid and potassium dihydrogenphosphate, the mixtures preferably having a phosphoric
acid content of 5 wt.% to 15 wt.% and a potassium dihydrogenphosphate content of
85 wt.% to 95 wt.%, calculated from the mixture to be compacted.
In order to facilitate mixing, the phosphorus source preferably is a material having
a grain diameter in the 50% range (d50) of 1 µm to 100 µm.
The content of the phosphorus source (calculated as PO43-)
in the mixture to be compacted is expediently in the range of 1 wt.% to 20 wt.%,
preferably 5 wt.% to 16 wt.%.
Prior to compaction the mixture of aluminium hydroxide and the phosphorus
source is as a rule homogenised in a suitable blending equipment.
Such equipment is known to those skilled in the art. Common equipment which can
be operated either continuously or discontinuously is available from several manufacturers,
e. g. Bepex Hosokawa (Nauta blender), from Lödige or from Eirich.
Compaction is conveniently carried out with equipment and according to methods
known by those skilled in the art. Compaction of aluminium hydroxide is for instance
exemplified in DE-C-25 14 758.
Usually the blended and homogenised material is fed in a screw conveyor unit which
has the task to constantly feed the pre-compressed material in the compactor.
A preferred compactor unit can be characterised by two counterrotating
rollers, one fixed and one movable, forming a narrow gap (nip) of variable width,
e. g. of 2 cm or less. The movable roller should be able to expose the feedstock
between the rollers to a compacting force of 50 kN to 200 kN per cm of nip length.
The result of the compaction treatment as a rule is a plate or a ribbon
with a thickness of e. g. 0.4 cm to 0.6 cm.
Size reduction usually comprises a series of steps. The compacted
material is as a rule first coarsely crushed in a suitable crushing unit. A further
intense size reduction can then for instance be achieved in a hammer crusher thereby,
depending on the outlet screen, the grain size coming down to a grain diameter of
e. g. 4 mm. Pre-classification and screening can then be accomplished in e. g. a
screening sizer unit, thereby finally obtaining a granule-like material.
In a preferred embodiment, after this size reduction steps at least 95 wt.% of
the particles have a particle size of between 0.1 mm and 1.5 mm, the most preferred
diameter being e. g. 0.5 mm to 1.5 mm.
The apparent density (as determined with a Hg-porosimeter at low pressure) of the
granules obtained ranges in general between 2.2 and 2.4 g/cm3.
All the means for size reduction and classification are well known
to those skilled in the art.
The activation of the compacted granules takes place in a suitable
kiln or oven. Good results have been achieved in an indirectly fired rotary kiln
(without lining) wherein the granules are treated at a temperature of 350 °C to
800 °C, preferably 350 °C to 600 °C. The preferred temperature at the shell of the
kiln has been determined to be between 650 °C and 750 °C.
The activated phosphorus doped alumina granules can finally be further
processed with respect to granule size distribution.
As a rule, 90 wt.% of the activated phosphorus doped alumina granules have a grain
diameter smaller than 1.25 mm.
The average particle size in the 50% range (d50) of the activated
material is preferably in the range of 0.5 mm to 1.0 mm.
The bulk density of the activated material is expediently between 650 g/l and 950
g/l, whereas the pycnometric density is about 3.1-3.2 g/cm3.
The quality of the activation can be controlled over the specific
surface area (measured according to BET) and the loss on ignition (LOI) of the activated
material. The surface area of the activated material should expediently be in the
range of 120 m2/g to 380 m2/g, preferably in the range of
250 m2/g to 320 m2/g. The loss on ignition of the activated
material preferably lies between 1% and 15%, most preferably 4% to 10%.
The activated phosphorus doped alumina granules produced with the
present process of the invention preferably have a phosphorus content between 50
g PO43-/kg and 150 g PO43-/kg (5 to
15 wt.%).
The granular phosphorus doped aluminas produced according to the invention
are therefore capable of providing aqueous solutions, e. g. the aqueous phase in
the growth media of horticultural plants, with phosphorus in a wide concentration
range and are thus well-suited as growth regulators.
Depending on the phosphorus source used, the growth media can further
be provided with the respective cation of the phosphorus source, e. g. with potassium,
magnesium and/or calcium as well as zinc, iron or copper, elements which also play
an important role as nutrient or micronutrient elements.
The desorption of phosphorus and optional other nutrient elements
from the activated alumina depends on the concentration of phosphorus and the other
nutrient elements in the activated phosphorus doped alumina granules as well as
on the pH of the buffer solution. It has been found that the phosphorus doped alumina
granules according to the invention have in fact buffering properties, i. e., they
do not only supply phosphorus to the media via desorption, but may also absorb excess
phosphorus from the media.
It has been found that, depending on the buffer system employed, a
predictable desorption of phosphorus, resulting in a phosphorus concentration in
the liquid phase in the range of about 5 to 5000 µM, can be achieved. Especially
when used as low-P buffer in potted plants, low and controlled phosphorus concentrations,
usually in the range of 5 to 100 µM, preferably 10 to 50 µM, can surprisingly be
provided throughout the whole production period of the respective potted plant.
These low phosphorus concentrations, which are at least about twenty times lower
than standard concentrations in nutrient solutions, showed strong growth retarding
effect without reducing plant quality.
The granular phosphorus doped activated aluminas according to the
invention can also be characterised by a phosphorus content (calculated as PO43-)
of 1 to 20 wt.%, a specific surface area (according to BET) of 120 to 380 m2/g,
a moisture content (determined at 300 °C) of less than 5%, preferably less than
1.5%, and a loss on ignition (determined at 1200 °C) of 1% to 15%, preferably 4%
to 10%.
Preferably, they have an average particle size in the 50% range (d50)
of 0.5 mm to 1.0 mm. The activated phosphorus doped alumina granules of the present
invention show a great potential to reduce or even replace chemical growth regulation
in several species of plants. The method has so far been found to be suited for
large-scale produced crops or flowering potted plants such as asters (Aster novi-belgii),
marguerite daisies (Argeranthemum frutescens), Poinsettia (Poinsettia
pulcherrima), miniature roses (Rosa-hybrid), Persian violet (Exacum
affine) and chrysanthemum (Dendranthema grandiflorum-hybrid) having considerable
need for growth regulation. The species represent a large diversity, both with regard
to the type of chemical growth regulators traditionally used by the industry and
the number of applications (amount) required for sufficient growth regulation. All
species have shown a strong and similar response to low phosphorus availability.
Besides the growth regulating properties based on their phosphorus
buffer activity, the activated phosphorus doped alumina granules of the present
invention show several further advantageous features.
It has been found that they also exhibit pH buffering properties and
may therefore used as pH buffers in the growing media of plants, preferably potted
plants. This is of particular importance for growing media based on materials having
little buffer capacity.
Furthermore, it has been found that they are also capable of desorbing
nutrients other than phosphorus (e. g., potassium) in a predictable and controllable
manner and may therefore act as potassium buffers. This is particularly surprising
as phosphorus doped alumina prepared according to prior art methods (US-A-5 693
119) was found to show only very poor potassium desorption.
Another surprising feature is their ability to improve peat-based
growing media which - depending on the origin and quality of the peat - often exhibit
growth- and/or germination-inhibiting properties due to a content of certain soluble
organic compounds. It has been found that the germination- and/or growth rates of
several plant species on peat of poor quality can be increased considerably by addition
of activated phosphorus doped alumina according to the present invention. Good results
have been obtained with e. g. buckwheat (Fagopyrum esculentum Moench.), cress
(Lepidium sativum L.), Chinese cabbage (Brassica rapa L. ssp.pekinensis
Lour.), lettuce (Lactuca sativa L. and tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum
Mill.). This product may therefore be used as an ameliorating agent for peat-based
growing media for plants.
Still another advantageous property of the activated phosphorus doped
alumina according to the present invention is its ability to supply several micronutrients
(e. g., Mn, Fe, Cu, Zn, Mo) and control their concentration in the growing media
of plants, preferably potted plants, by desorption or absorption. It has, for example,
been found that it is able to reduce the iron content below the toxic concentrations
sometimes encountered in the culture of iron-sensitive species such as
Pentas lanceolata by absorbing iron from the growing media.
The following non-limiting examples illustrate several embodiments
of the invention. The physical and chemical characteristics of the product were
measured according to standard methods, for example ISO 803 (moisture content, determined
at 300 °C) and ISO 806 (loss on ignition, determined at 1200 °C).
Examples:
1. Production of a phosphorus doped alumina
1.1 Discontinuous production of a medium-P buffer
Dry aluminium trihydroxide (Al(OH)3, 1500 kg) with the
following specification:
- Moisture: 0.45 wt.%
- Na2O content: 0.29 wt.% (referred to Al2O3)
- Loss on ignition (LOI): 34.9 wt.%
- Bulk density: 1120 g/l
- Grain size distribution:
- >150 µm: 16.8 wt.%
- >106 µm: 55.6 wt.%
- >75 µm: 75.6 wt.%
- <45 µm: 12.4 wt.%
was discontinuously blended and homogenised for 30 min with 25.7 kg of orthophosphoric
acid (85wt.%, technical quality) and 135 kg of monopotassium dihydrogenphosphate
(KH2PO4, technical quality, average grain size d50
= 50 µm) using a Nauta blender. This material was stored in a silo before using.
Then a constant feed of 1200 kg/h was pre-densified in a screw conveyor unit and
subsequently compacted between two rotating rollers forming a nip (gap) having a
length of 15 cm. The roller diameter was 52 cm. The rollers were pressed together
by hydraulic means, the measured (hydraulic) pressure being 200 bar corresponding
to a compacting force of ca. 108 kN/cm in the nip. The resulting compacted ribbon/plate
had a thickness (corresponding to the nip width) ranging between 4 and 6 mm. In
the next step, the compacted aluminium trihydroxide plate was crushed using a single-roll
crusher ("fissator"). Granules finer than 1 mm were separated from the process by
screening. Further intense crushing was realised in a hammer crusher with an outlet
screen size of 4 mm. Pre-classification and screening was carried out by a screening
sizer (undersize: <0.71 mm; oversize: >1.12 mm). The "go"-fraction was stored
in a silo. A constant product feed (1100 kg/h) was activated in an indirectly fired
rotary kiln (unlined steel shell, total length ca. 9 m, length of heated zone 7.2
m, diameter 90 cm, inclination 1°) rotating at approx. 2 rpm, wherein the granules
were treated at a shell temperature of 750 °C for about 1 h. After activation the
product was screened to obtain a fraction having 0.315 to 1.25 mm particle size.
The final product had the following characteristics:
- Specific surface area (BET): 265 m2/g
- Loss on ignition: 5.4 wt.%
- Na2Ototal: 0.21 wt.% (referred to Al2O3)
- Moisture (at 300 °C): 0.65 wt.%
- Bulk density: 765 g/l
- Pycnometric density: 3.14 g/cm3
- Grain size distribution:
- >1.00 mm: 8.0 wt.%
- >0.50 mm: 82.7 wt.%
- >0.315 mm: 98.7 wt.%
- PO43- content: 9.6 wt.%
- K2O content: 3.9 wt.%
1.2 Continuous production of low to medium phosphorus buffers
1350 kg/h of a dried aluminium trihydroxide (Al(OH)3),
with the following specification:
- moisture: 0.2 wt.%
- Na2O content: 0.33 wt.% (referred to Al2O3)
- Loss on ignition (LOI): 34.7 wt.%
- Bulk density: 1200 g/l
- Grain size distribution:
- >200 µm: 1.6 wt.%
- >150 µm: 11.9 wt.%
- >75 µm: 82.4 wt.%
- <45 µm: 3.1 wt.%
was continuously blended and homogenised with orthophosphoric acid (85 wt.%, technical
quality) at a feed rate F1 and monopotassium dihydrogenphosphate (KH2PO4,
technical quality, average grain size d50 = 25 µm) at a feed rate
F2 using a Nauta blender. This feed was pre-densified in a pre-compression screw
conveyor unit. The power consumption of the screw conveyor was controlled in order
to ensure a constant feed rate to the subsequently working roller-type compactor.
Then the mixture was compacted between two counterrotating rollers forming a nip
(cf. preceding example). The measured hydraulic pressure was 195 bar, corresponding
to a compacting force of ca. 105 kN/cm. The resulting compacted ribbon/plate had
a thickness ranging between 4 mm and 6 mm. In the next step, the compacted aluminium
trihydroxide plate was crushed using a single-roll crusher ("fissator"). Granules
finer than 1 mm were separated from the process by sieving. Further intense crushing
was realised in a hammer crusher with an outlet screen size of 4 mm. Pre-classification
and screening was carried out by a screening sizer (undersize: <0.71 mm; oversize:
>1.25 mm). The "go"-fraction was stored in a silo. A constant product feed (1000
kg/h) was activated in an indirectly fired rotary kiln (details see above) wherein
the granules were treated at a shell temperature of 730 °C. After activation the
product was screened to obtain a particle size between 0.315 mm and 1.25 mm. The
final products had the following characteristics listed in the table below:
Example No.
1.2.1
1.2.2
1.2.3
1.2.4
1.2.5
1.2.6
F1 [kg/h]
11.5
11.5
11.5
11.5
11.5
11.5
F2 [kg/h]
3.0
12.7
49.7
66.2
118.5
250.7
Surface area (BET) [m2/g]
303
296
305
294
297
260
Loss on ignition [wt.%]
6.5
6.6
7.8
7.8
5.6
7.6
Bulk density [g/l]
815
825
805
725
680
685
Granule size distribution [wt.%]
>1.25 mm
8.2
1.8
5.3
4.6
6.1
3.5
>1.00 mm
38.3
26.2
34.8
27.2
31.1
31.7
>0.5 mm
92.5
89.7
91.2
86.7
93.2
88.3
>0.315 mm
99.8
98.2
99.5
99.7
99.3
99.4
PO43- [wt.%]
1.2
1.9
4.3
5.5
8.6
14.6
K2O [wt.%]
0.11
0.45
1.7
2.3
3.8
7.0
2. Desorption and plant tests
Desorption of phosphorus from the six samples 1.2.1 to 1.2.6 was tested
using Poinsettia as model plant. The following standard growing procedure
for Poinsettia was followed except for phosphorus being provided with the
phosphorus doped activated alumina.
Propagation:
Cuttings were propagated in peat at high phosphorus concentration
(approx. 500 µM P) at a conventional greenhouse operation. After propagation the
roots were rinsed free of the peat they were propagated in and transplanted into
a P-free peat mixed with 2 wt.% phosphorus doped activated alumina.
Treatments:
Growth media was mixed with 2 wt.% of a sample of the phosphorus doped
activated alumina of examples 1.2.1 to 1.2.6. Soil solution samples were taken after
each irrigation and the samples were analysed for plant available phosphorus once
weekly. The treatments started mid October and the plants were grown vegetatively
until early January of the following year when they were harvested.
Replicates and statistics:
The experiment was designed as a randomised block design with two
replicates per treatment.
Temperature:
20 °C day/night until 4 weeks after the treatment started, hereafter
18 °C during the rest of the production period.
Supplemental lighting:
Poinsettia requires short days (10-h day, 14-h night) for floral
induction. The experiment was conducted during late fall and winter with natural
short days.
20 hours of supplemental lighting was employed (60 µmol photons m-2
s-1) in order to keep the plants vegetative and to characterise maximum
growth potential of the non-chemical growth regulated plants.
Irrigation:
Plants were irrigated once or twice every week with a solution providing:
NH4: 1 mM; NO3: 11.3 mM; K: 4.6 mM; Ca: 3.5 mM; Mg: 0.7 mM;
Fe: 39.4 µM; Mn: 17.9 µM; B: 6.4 µM; Cu: 13.9 µM; Zn: 3.8 µM; Mo: 0.8 µM; Na: 0.2
µM; SO,: 0.7 µM.
pH: 5.8-6.0
CO2: 700 ppm
Growth regulation:
No chemical growth regulation was employed.
Data collection:
Ten weeks after transplanting 16 plants per treatment were harvested
and the following was recorded:
Plant height:
Plant height was measured from the edge of the container to the apical
meristem.
Fresh weight:
The fresh weight of leaves and stems was measured immediately after
the shoot was excised from the root.
Dry weight:
The dry weight of leaves and stems was measured after 24 h of drying
at 70 °C.
Description of the drawings:
- Figure 1 shows the phosphorus desorption of the six samples (1.2.1 to
1.2.6) of phosphorus doped activated alumina obtained in example 1.2.
Phosphorus desorption from several of the samples was low and stable, especially
two of the samples (no. 4 and 5) showed low phosphorus desorption within the range
required for an efficient growth regulation. The time dependency of phosphorus desorption
was small in the samples where phosphorus desorption was low (nos. 1-5, see error
bars) compared with that of sample no. 6 desorbing relatively high phosphorus concentrations.
- Figure 2 shows the influence of the phosphorus desorption of the same
six samples of phosphorus doped activated alumina on plant height. An efficient
growth retardant effect was determined when plants were grown with low phosphorus
concentration provided from phosphorus doped activated alumina.
- Figure 3 shows the influence of the phosphorus desorption of the six
samples of phosphorus doped activated alumina on plant fresh weight. Plant fresh
weight was affected to a lesser extent than plant height.
- Figure 4 shows the influence of the phosphorus desorption of the six
samples of phosphorus doped activated alumina on plant dry weight. Also plant dry
weight was affected to a lesser extent than plant height.
- Figure 5 shows the pH buffering behaviour of two different products according
to the invention ("Low-P buffer" and "High-P buffer") during the production of
Argeranthemum frutescens on peat based growing media. In one case, a common
chemical growth retardant (cycocel, "CCC") was used in addition to High-P buffer
while in one comparison example (solid square dots) only dissolved phosphate was
used together with cycocel.
- Figure 6 shows the pH dependency of the potassium desorption from phosphorus
doped activated alumina according to the invention. One part (per weight) of alumina
was added to five parts of demineralised water. The diagram shows high potassium
desorption in the pH range prevailing in plant culture (5.5-6).
- Figure 7 shows the influence of the phosphorus doped activated alumina
according to the invention on the growth rate of tomatoe (Lycopersicon esculentum
Mill.) grown on different peat qualities. The solid bars refer to the results with
addition of 2 vol.% phosphorus doped activated alumina while the hollow bars refer
to the results obtained without addition. The peat categories were:
- (1) peat without any known problems (control)
- (2) lithuanian peat without fertilizer and not limed
- (3) peat where self-heating had occured
- (4) peat where problems had been identified in potted plant nurseries, samples
taken prior to plant cultivation
- (5) same as (4), samples taken after plant cultivation.
Five seeds were sown per pot and the plants were irrigated with a weak nutrient
solution (EC 1.6, pH 6.0). The plant dry weight was determined after 4 weeks.
- Figure 8 shows the root area (measured on the bottom of the pot) of tomato
grown under the same conditions as described above for Fig. 7.
- Figure 9 shows the germination rate of tomato measured 10 days after
sowing. The other conditions were the same as described above for Fig. 7.