This invention relates to a method for enhancing the cooking step
in a tall oil preparation process comprising a neutralisation step, in which soap
is neutralised to form soap oil, and a cooking step, in which soap oil is cooked
with sulphuric acid to form tall oil. The invention also relates to a method for
preparing tall oil comprising the steps above.
In the alkaline digestion of softwood or hardwood, especially in the
sulphate method, "black liquor" is formed, which contains crude tall oil soap, called
crude soap below. This crude soap can be decomposed by means of sulphuric acid to
form crude tall oil.
US patent specification 3 901 869 discloses a process for preparing
tall oil based on carbon dioxide neutralisation. In the first step of this known
process, crude soap is neutralised with carbon dioxide and after this step water
is separated and finally tall oil cook is performed by means of sulphuric acid.
When crude tall oil is treated with carbon dioxide, carbon dioxide dissolves in
the soap/water emulsion and the carbon oxide formed neutralises soap and the lye
accompanying it. The pH of the soap/water mixture can be decreased to the range
7.5-8.2 by neutralisation. This known method involves the drawback of poor water
separation. Poor water separation results in excess consumption of sulphuric acid
in the subsequent cook, and the water surplus expands the process cycles unnecessarily.
A surplus of water containing CO2 also entails effervescence in the sulphuric
acid cook, because bicarbonate decomposes when cooked.
WO Patent Application 94/11571 discloses a method for preparing tall
oil by first performing preoxidation with a sodium bisulphate solution, followed
by a tall oil cook with sulphuric acid.
FI Patent Application 940969 describes a method, in which carbon dioxide
neutralisation is followed by a second neutralisation by means of an H2SO4
addition. With this procedure, soap separation in the water separation step was
improved compared to a method where no intermediate neutralisation with sulphuric
acid was performed. After this intermediate neutralisation, a tall oil cook is performed
by means of sulphuric acid.
FI Patent Application 952176 discloses a similar method, in which
the sulphuric acid used for intermediate neutralisation is replaced with an acidly
reacting substance containing bisulphite.
The purpose of the invention is to further improve the tall oil preparation
process, particularly the cooking step of the process.
The chief characteristics of the invention are defined in the accompanying
claims.
Thus, the invention provides a method for enhancing the cooking step
in a tall oil preparation process comprising:
- a neutralisation step, in which soap is neutralised to form soap oil, and a
cooking step, in which soap oil is cooked with sulphuric acid to form tall oil,
the method being characterised by the fact that the soap oil obtained in the neutralisation
step is subjected to an intermediate treatment before the cooking step, the intermediate
treatment comprising heating the soap oil in order to release gases dissolved in
and bound to the soap oil.
In addition, the invention provides a method for preparing tall oil
comprising:
- a neutralisation step, in which soap is neutralised to form soap oil, and a
cooking step, in which soap oil is cooked with sulphuric acid to form tall oil,
the method being characterised by the fact that it also comprises an intermediate
treatment, in which the soap oil obtained in the neutralisation step is heated before
the cooking step in order to release gases dissolved in and bound to the soap oil,
thereby facilitating the cook and enhancing the phase separation following the cook.
Owing to the intermediate treatment of the invention, soap oil is
easier to cook, i.e. the final cook requires less sulphuric acid and/or shorter
cooking periods, and the phase separation following the cook is rapid.
The intermediate treatment mentioned above is a separate step between
the neutralisation step and the cooking step, and no chemicals are added in this
step. The intermediate treatment can be performed in a separate reactor, but it
is also possible to perform the intermediate treatment and the cooking step consecutively
in the same reactor.
The intermediate treatment is preferably performed at a temperature
in the approximate range from 60 to 100 °C, and most preferably at a temperature
in the approximate range from 90 to 98 °C. The intermediate treatment duration is
preferably 5 minutes or more, and most preferably approximately 5 to 30 minutes.
The neutralisation step in accordance with the invention may comprise
neutralisation of soap with an acidly reacting substance, which is preferably carbon
dioxide, bisulphite, sulphur dioxide or carboxylic acid, or a mixture of these.
The neutralisation step of the invention may also comprise soap neutralisation
first with carbon dioxide and then with a second acidly reacting substance, which
is preferably bisulphite, sulphur dioxide, sulphuric acid, hydrochloric acid, nitric
acid or carboxylic acid, or a combination of these.
The carboxylic acid mentioned above may be for instance formic acid.
The bisulphite used for neutralisation may consist of a residual solution
produced in the additional scrubbing of sulphurous flue gases from a pulp mill,
the solution containing sodium sulphite (Na2SO3) besides sodium
bisulphite (NaHSO3).
The neutralisation step preferably comprises neutralisation with carbon
dioxide. CO2 neutralisation can be performed under normal pressure or
over-pressure, typically under a pressure of about 8 105 Pa (8 bar).
The carbon dioxide used is preferably a carbon dioxide gas.
The intermediate treatment is preferably conducted under atmospheric
pressure, however, hihger or lower pressures can also be applied.
In this invention, the term "soap oil" denotes crude soap pre-neutralised
with carbon dioxide or some other acid chemical.
The invention is described in greater detail below with reference
to the accompanying drawings, of which
- figure 1 is a block diagram of a tall oil preparation process in accordance
with the invention, and
- figure 2 is a graphic chart of comparative test results.
In figure 1, soap oil, which is crude soap pre-neutralised with carbon
dioxide or some other acid chemical, is introduced in the intermediate tall oil
treatment step. In a preferred embodiment, this intermediate step can be performed
as follows:
Soap oil is fed into a heat exchanger or a direct steam heater, in
which the temperature of the soap oil is raised to the temperature range from 60
to 100 °C. The temperature may be even higher than this, especially if pressures
higher than the atmospheric pressure are applied. The temperature may for instance
equal the boiling point of the mixture. Soap oil contains physical and chemical
CO2 gas bonds of an organic substance, the bonds breaking up during heating,
so that gases are released. Besides carbon dioxide, also other gases are released
during heating.
The heated flow of soap oil and gas is conducted to a gas separation
vessel, where the gases are separated from the soap oil and the reactions end. The
major portion of the gases is released during 5 minutes, the mixture being highly
effervescent. The temperature of the gas separation vessel is kept at 60 to 100
°C. The temperature of the vessel may equal the boiling point of the mixture, which
depends on the pressure. Normally atmospheric pressure prevails in the vessel. The
pressure may also be higher or lower than the atmospheric pressure. The retention
time of tall oil in the gas separation vessel is normally 10 minutes, but may also
be shorter or longer depending on the temperature applied. The vessel is equipped
with a heating coil, but heating may also be performed with direct steam. The gas
separation vessel comprises a mixer, which enhances gas separation and breaks the
foam bed.
After the intermediate soap oil treatment, soap oil is introduced
in a conventional tall oil cooker, where conventional final cook of the tall oil
is performed with sulphuric acid. From this conventional final cook, the product
is conducted to oil separation, where tall oil is separated from lignin and pulp
press water.
In accordance with the invention, soap oil which has been subjected
to intermediate treatment is more readily digested in the final cook, the temperature
required for the cook being easier to reach as the production of gases cooling the
mixture is reduced. The lignin/pulp press phase is also different from that of digestion
without an intermediate treatment. The oil is more rapidly separated in the tall
oil separation step than in a process without an intermediate step.
The invention is further described below with the aid of examples.
Examples
In the following examples, soap oil was prepared by pre-neutralising
crude soap with carbon dioxide as follows:
Crude soap (pH about 13) is pumped into a neutralising reactor, preceded
by water addition to the soap flow. The reactor is supplied with carbon dioxide,
which is dispersed into the soap/water emulsion with a mixer, thus reacting with
the water forming carbon oxide, and is then mixed as carbon dioxide with crude soap
under a pressure of approx 8 105 Pa (8 bar).
The reaction product (pH of about 8) flows into the gas separation
reactor, from which the inert gases are removed.
From the gas separation rector, the mixture flows into static mixers,
preceded by sulphuric acid addition to enhance the separation of pulp press water
and soap oil (a final pH of approx. 7) (intermediate neutralisation).
After the mixers the mixture of soap oil and pulp press water is conducted
to a separation vessel, where two phases are formed, with soap oil on the surface
and pulp press water at the bottom.
The soap oil is stripped from the surface of the separation vessel
and is pumped forward in the process.
Crude soap processed as described above is called soap oil.
The next comparative example 1 represents conventional techniques,
whereas examples 1 to 5 represent the procedure of the invention. In the examples,
the tall oil separation was determined by measuring the amount of tall oil (ml)
as a function of time (min.). The results are shown in accompanying figure 2.
In all of the examples, the cooking reactor was a 1,000 ml decanter
vessel equipped with a mixer. The vessel was heated on an electric hotplate and
the temperature of the soap oil was adjusted by means of a contact thermometer.
The tall oil separation was determined using a 1 litre gauge glass. The quality
of the tall oil separated in all of the tests was good.
Comparative example 1
500 g of soap oil was weighed and 50 g of water ws added to this.
The mixture of soap oil and water was heated to a temperature of 80 °C and 30 g
(95 to 97%) of sulphuric acid was added. The acidified mixture was cooked for 30
minutes at a temperature of 100 °C during constant stirring at a rate of about 100
rpm. After the cook, the mixture was poured into a gauge glass. The tall oil separation
that was determined is shown in figure 2.
Example 1
500 g of soap oil was weighed and 50 g of water was added to this.
The mixture of soap oil and water was subjected to intermediate treatment at a temperature
from 90 to 95 °C for 10 minutes while the mixture was stirred. After this, 30 g
(95 to 97%) of sulphuric acid was added. The sulphuric acid addition was performed
for 5 seconds. The final cook took 10 minutes in all, and then the mixture was poured
into a gauge glass.
Example 2
In this example, no water was added to the soap oil (nor was it added
in examples 3 to 5). Before the actual cooking to form oil, the soap oil was subjected
to an intermediate treatment for 20 minutes at a temperature of 80 °C while stirring.
In the intermediate treatment step, gas/soap oil foam was produced in abundance,
starting at as low a temperature as approx. 60 °C. After the intermediate treatment
step, 30 g of sulphuric acid was added to the mixture and the mixture was cooked
for 30 minutes at a temperature of 100 °C while stirring. Then the mixture was poured
into a gauge glas. The analysis of the separated tall oil was: 0.9% of H2O,
acid number 155, soap number 0.0 and pH 3.6
Example 3
In this example, the temperature of the intermediate treatment step
was 90 °C and it lasted 20 minutes. After this 30 g of sulphuric acid was added
to the mixture and the mixture was first stirred rapidly (about 100 rpm) and then
slower (30 rpm). The temperature of the mixture was 101-97 °C in the cooking step.
After this the mixture was transferred into a gauge glass. The oil was separated
fairly rapidly. The analysis of the separated tall oil was: 1.1% of H2O,
acid number 150, soap number 0.0 and pH 3.4.
Example 4
The purpose of this example was to optimise sulphuric acid consumption
in the cook. The mixture was subjected to intermediate treatment for 30 minutes
at a temperature of 90 °C. After this sulphuric acid was added to adjust the pH
of the mixture. The total amount of sulphuric acid addition was 25.3 g, the final
pH being 3.03. Oil separation was fast in the beginning, but slowed down somewhat
at the end. Yet the overall separation process was rapid in this test. The analysis
of the separated tall oil was: 2.1% of H2O, acid number 150, soap number
0.01 and pH 4.1.
Example 5
In this example, the intermediate treatment step was similar to that
of example 4 (30 minutes, 90 °C). 25 g of sulphuric acid was added without pH monitoring
to the mixture which had been subjected to intermediate treatment, the acid addition
taking place faster than in example 4. The analysis of the separated tall oil was:
2.1 % of H2O, acid number 150, soap number 0.03 and pH 4.1.
Data on the exemplified tests are compiled in table 1. The separation
curves shown in figure 2 lead to the conclusion that examples 1, 4 and 5 of the
invention yielded the best results. The tests indicated the following optimal conditions
in terms of separation: temperature ≥ 90 °C, preferably 90 to 98 °C and precooking
period ≥ approx. 5 minutes, preferably about 5 to 30 minutes. The rate of adding
sulphuric acid also affects separability in such a way that rapid addition promotes
oil separation.
Summary of the tests
Example
Soap oil, g
Water, g
Intermed. treatm. temp. °C
Interm. treatm. duration min.
Amount of sulph. acid g (95-97%)
N.B.
Comp. 1
500
50
-
-
30
Comparative test
1
500
50
90-95
10
30
Rapid H2SO4 addition
2
500
-
80
20
30
3
500
-
90
20
30
4
500
-
90
30
25.3
5
500
-
90
30
25
Rapid H2SO4 addition
A separate test aimed to settle the amount and composition of gas
released from the soap oil. To this end, soap oil (638.2 g) was heated in a closed
glass reactor at a temperature of 90 °C. The gas released in the reactor gas space
was collected into a sample bag for one hour. The volume of collected dry gas was
540 ml. It had the following analysis:
H2
<0.1
% by volume
O2+ Ar
4.6
"
CH4
<0.05
"
CO
<0.05
"
CO2
73.2
"
H2S
approx.1,400
ppm
SO2
approx. 2
ppm
N2
remainder
The CO2 concentration of the soap oil was also determined
before and after the intermediate treatment. The concentration was 0.42% before
the intermediate treatment and 0.16% after the intermediate treatment.
Tests have also proved that the use of the method of the invention
reduces the amount of acid required in the final cook.